Asynchronous constructor
Javascriptnode.jsAsynchronousConstructorJavascript Problem Overview
How can I best handle a situation like the following?
I have a constructor that takes a while to complete.
var Element = function Element(name){
this.name = name;
this.nucleus = {};
this.load_nucleus(name); // This might take a second.
}
var oxygen = new Element('oxygen');
console.log(oxygen.nucleus); // Returns {}, because load_nucleus hasn't finished.
I see three options, each of which seem out of the ordinary.
One, add a callback to the constructor.
var Element = function Element(name, fn){
this.name = name;
this.nucleus = {};
this.load_nucleus(name, function(){
fn(); // Now continue.
});
}
Element.prototype.load_nucleus(name, fn){
fs.readFile(name+'.json', function(err, data) {
this.nucleus = JSON.parse(data);
fn();
});
}
var oxygen = new Element('oxygen', function(){
console.log(oxygen.nucleus);
});
Two, use EventEmitter to emit a 'loaded' event.
var Element = function Element(name){
this.name = name;
this.nucleus = {};
this.load_nucleus(name); // This might take a second.
}
Element.prototype.load_nucleus(name){
var self = this;
fs.readFile(name+'.json', function(err, data) {
self.nucleus = JSON.parse(data);
self.emit('loaded');
});
}
util.inherits(Element, events.EventEmitter);
var oxygen = new Element('oxygen');
oxygen.once('loaded', function(){
console.log(this.nucleus);
});
Or three, block the constructor.
var Element = function Element(name){
this.name = name;
this.nucleus = {};
this.load_nucleus(name); // This might take a second.
}
Element.prototype.load_nucleus(name, fn){
this.nucleus = JSON.parse(fs.readFileSync(name+'.json'));
}
var oxygen = new Element('oxygen');
console.log(oxygen.nucleus)
But I haven't seen any of this done before.
What other options do I have?
Javascript Solutions
Solution 1 - Javascript
Update 2: Here is an updated example using an asynchronous factory method. N.B. this requires Node 8 or Babel if run in a browser.
class Element {
constructor(nucleus){
this.nucleus = nucleus;
}
static async createElement(){
const nucleus = await this.loadNucleus();
return new Element(nucleus);
}
static async loadNucleus(){
// do something async here and return it
return 10;
}
}
async function main(){
const element = await Element.createElement();
// use your element
}
main();
Update: The code below got upvoted a couple of times. However I find this approach using a static method much better: https://stackoverflow.com/a/24686979/2124586
ES6 version using promises
class Element{
constructor(){
this.some_property = 5;
this.nucleus;
return new Promise((resolve) => {
this.load_nucleus().then((nucleus) => {
this.nucleus = nucleus;
resolve(this);
});
});
}
load_nucleus(){
return new Promise((resolve) => {
setTimeout(() => resolve(10), 1000)
});
}
}
//Usage
new Element().then(function(instance){
// do stuff with your instance
});
Solution 2 - Javascript
Given the necessity to avoid blocking in Node, the use of events or callbacks isn't so strange(1).
With a slight edit of Two, you could merge it with One:
var Element = function Element(name, fn){
this.name = name;
this.nucleus = {};
if (fn) this.on('loaded', fn);
this.load_nucleus(name); // This might take a second.
}
...
Though, like the fs.readFile in your example, the core Node APIs (at least) often follow the pattern of static functions that expose the instance when the data is ready:
var Element = function Element(name, nucleus) {
this.name = name;
this.nucleus = nucleus;
};
Element.create = function (name, fn) {
fs.readFile(name+'.json', function(err, data) {
var nucleus = err ? null : JSON.parse(data);
fn(err, new Element(name, nucleus));
});
};
Element.create('oxygen', function (err, elem) {
if (!err) {
console.log(elem.name, elem.nucleus);
}
});
(1) It shouldn't take very long to read a JSON file. If it is, perhaps a change in storage system is in order for the data.
Solution 3 - Javascript
I have developed an async constructor:
function Myclass(){
return (async () => {
... code here ...
return this;
})();
}
(async function() {
let s=await new Myclass();
console.log("s",s)
})();
- [async returns a promise][1]
- [arrow functions pass 'this' as is][2]
- it is possible to return something else when doing new (you still get a new empty object in this variable. if you call the function without new. you get the original this. like maybe window or global or its holding object).
- it is possible to return the return value of called async function using await.
- to use await in normal code, need to wrap the calls with an async anonymous function, that is called instantly. (the called function returns promise and code continues)
my 1st iteration was:
maybe just add a callback
call an anonymous async function, then call the callback.
function Myclass(cb){
var asynccode=(async () => {
await this.something1();
console.log(this.result)
})();
if(cb)
asynccode.then(cb.bind(this))
}
my 2nd iteration was:
let's try with a promise instead of a callback. I thought to myself: strange a promise returning a promise, and it worked. .. so the next version is just a promise.
function Myclass(){
this.result=false;
var asynccode=(async () => {
await new Promise (resolve => setTimeout (()=>{this.result="ok";resolve()}, 1000))
console.log(this.result)
return this;
})();
return asynccode;
}
(async function() {
let s=await new Myclass();
console.log("s",s)
})();
callback-based for old javascript
function Myclass(cb){
var that=this;
var cb_wrap=function(data){that.data=data;cb(that)}
getdata(cb_wrap)
}
new Myclass(function(s){
});
[1]: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/JavaScript/Reference/Statements/async_function "async keyword" [2]: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/JavaScript/Reference/Functions/Arrow_functions "more about arrow functions"
Solution 4 - Javascript
One thing you could do is preload all the nuclei (maybe inefficient; I don't know how much data it is). The other, which I would recommend if preloading is not an option, would involve a callback with a cache to save loaded nuclei. Here is that approach:
Element.nuclei = {};
Element.prototype.load_nucleus = function(name, fn){
if ( name in Element.nuclei ) {
this.nucleus = Element.nuclei[name];
return fn();
}
fs.readFile(name+'.json', function(err, data) {
this.nucleus = Element.nuclei[name] = JSON.parse(data);
fn();
});
}
Solution 5 - Javascript
This is a bad code design.
The main problem is in the callback your instance it's not still execute the "return", this is what I mean
var MyClass = function(cb) {
doAsync(function(err) {
cb(err)
}
return {
method1: function() { },
method2: function() { }
}
}
var _my = new MyClass(function(err) {
console.log('instance', _my) // < _my is still undefined
// _my.method1() can't run any methods from _my instance
})
_my.method1() // < it run the function, but it's not yet inited
So, the good code design is to explicitly call the "init" method (or in your case "load_nucleus") after instanced the class
var MyClass = function() {
return {
init: function(cb) {
doAsync(function(err) {
cb(err)
}
},
method1: function() { },
method2: function() { }
}
}
var _my = new MyClass()
_my.init(function(err) {
if(err) {
console.error('init error', err)
return
}
console.log('inited')
// _my.method1()
})
Solution 6 - Javascript
I extract out the async portions into a fluent method. By convention I call them together.
class FooBar {
constructor() {
this.foo = "foo";
}
async create() {
this.bar = await bar();
return this;
}
}
async function bar() {
return "bar";
}
async function main() {
const foobar = await new FooBar().create(); // two-part constructor
console.log(foobar.foo, foobar.bar);
}
main(); // foo bar
I tried a static factory approach wrapping new FooBar(), e.g. FooBar.create(), but it didn't play well with inheritance. If you extend FooBar into FooBarChild, FooBarChild.create() will still return a FooBar. Whereas with my approach new FooBarChild().create() will return a FooBarChild and it's easy to setup an inheritance chain with create().
Solution 7 - Javascript
You can run constructor function with async functions synchronously via nsynjs. Here is an example to illustrate:
index.js (main app logic):
var nsynjs = require('nsynjs');
var modules = {
MyObject: require('./MyObject')
};
function synchronousApp(modules) {
try {
var myObjectInstance1 = new modules.MyObject('data1.json');
var myObjectInstance2 = new modules.MyObject('data2.json');
console.log(myObjectInstance1.getData());
console.log(myObjectInstance2.getData());
}
catch (e) {
console.log("Error",e);
}
}
nsynjs.run(synchronousApp,null,modules,function () {
console.log('done');
});
MyObject.js (class definition with slow constructor):
var nsynjs = require('nsynjs');
var synchronousCode = function (wrappers) {
var config;
// constructor of MyObject
var MyObject = function(fileName) {
this.data = JSON.parse(wrappers.readFile(nsynjsCtx, fileName).data);
};
MyObject.prototype.getData = function () {
return this.data;
};
return MyObject;
};
var wrappers = require('./wrappers');
nsynjs.run(synchronousCode,{},wrappers,function (m) {
module.exports = m;
});
wrappers.js (nsynjs-aware wrapper around slow functions with callbacks):
var fs=require('fs');
exports.readFile = function (ctx,name) {
var res={};
fs.readFile( name, "utf8", function( error , configText ){
if( error ) res.error = error;
res.data = configText;
ctx.resume(error);
} );
return res;
};
exports.readFile.nsynjsHasCallback = true;
Full set of files for this example could be found here: https://github.com/amaksr/nsynjs/tree/master/examples/node-async-constructor