How to create a HashMap with two keys (Key-Pair, Value)?

Java Problem Overview

I have a 2D array of Integers. I want them to be put into a HashMap. But I want to access the elements from the HashMap based on Array Index. Something like:

For A[2][5], map.get(2,5) which returns a value associated with that key. But how do I create a hashMap with a pair of keys? Or in general, multiple keys: Map<((key1, key2,..,keyN), Value) in a way that I can access the element with using get(key1,key2,...keyN).

EDIT : 3 years after posting the question, I want to add a bit more to it

I came across another way for NxN matrix.

Array indices, i and j can be represented as a single key the following way:

int key = i * N + j;
//map.put(key, a[i][j]); // queue.add(key);

And the indices can be retrevied from the key in this way:

int i = key / N;
int j = key % N;

Java Solutions

Solution 1 - Java

There are several options:

2 dimensions

Map of maps

Map<Integer, Map<Integer, V>> map = //...
//...

map.get(2).get(5);

Wrapper key object

public class Key {

	private final int x;
	private final int y;
	
	public Key(int x, int y) {
		this.x = x;
		this.y = y;
	}
	
	@Override
	public boolean equals(Object o) {
		if (this == o) return true;
		if (!(o instanceof Key)) return false;
		Key key = (Key) o;
		return x == key.x && y == key.y;
	}

	@Override
	public int hashCode() {
		int result = x;
		result = 31 * result + y;
		return result;
	}

}

Implementing equals() and hashCode() is crucial here. Then you simply use:

Map<Key, V> map = //...

and:

map.get(new Key(2, 5));

`Table` from Guava

Table<Integer, Integer, V> table = HashBasedTable.create();
//...

table.get(2, 5);

Table uses map of maps underneath.

N dimensions

Notice that special Key class is the only approach that scales to n-dimensions. You might also consider:

Map<List<Integer>, V> map = //...

but that's terrible from performance perspective, as well as readability and correctness (no easy way to enforce list size).

Maybe take a look at Scala where you have tuples and case classes (replacing whole Key class with one-liner).

Solution 2 - Java

When you create your own key pair object, you should face a few thing.

First, you should be aware of implementing hashCode() and equals(). You will need to do this.

Second, when implementing hashCode(), make sure you understand how it works. The given user example

public int hashCode() {
    return this.x ^ this.y;
}

is actually one of the worst implementations you can do. The reason is simple: you have a lot of equal hashes! And the hashCode() should return int values that tend to be rare, unique at it's best. Use something like this:

public int hashCode() {
  return (X << 16) + Y;
}

This is fast and returns unique hashes for keys between -2^16 and 2^16-1 (-65536 to 65535). This fits in almost any case. Very rarely you are out of this bounds.

Third, when implementing equals() also know what it is used for and be aware of how you create your keys, since they are objects. Often you do unnecessary if statements cause you will always have the same result.

If you create keys like this: map.put(new Key(x,y),V); you will never compare the references of your keys. Cause everytime you want to acces the map, you will do something like map.get(new Key(x,y));. Therefore your equals() does not need a statement like if (this == obj). It will never occure.

Instead of if (getClass() != obj.getClass()) in your equals() better use if (!(obj instanceof this)). It will be valid even for subclasses.

So the only thing you need to compare is actually X and Y. So the best equals() implementation in this case would be:

public boolean equals (final Object O) {
  if (!(O instanceof Key)) return false;
  if (((Key) O).X != X) return false;
  if (((Key) O).Y != Y) return false;
  return true;
}

So in the end your key class is like this:

public class Key {

  public final int X;
  public final int Y;

  public Key(final int X, final int Y) {
    this.X = X;
    this.Y = Y;
  }

  public boolean equals (final Object O) {
    if (!(O instanceof Key)) return false;
    if (((Key) O).X != X) return false;
    if (((Key) O).Y != Y) return false;
    return true;
  }

  public int hashCode() {
    return (X << 16) + Y;
  }
    
}

You can give your dimension indices X and Y a public access level, due to the fact they are final and do not contain sensitive information. I'm not a 100% sure whether private access level works correctly in any case when casting the Object to a Key.

If you wonder about the finals, I declare anything as final which value is set on instancing and never changes - and therefore is an object constant.

Solution 3 - Java

You can't have an hash map with multiple keys, but you can have an object that takes multiple parameters as the key.

Create an object called Index that takes an x and y value.

public class Index {
    
    private int x;
    private int y;
    
    public Index(int x, int y) {
        this.x = x;
        this.y = y;
    }

    @Override
    public int hashCode() {
        return this.x ^ this.y;
    }

    @Override
    public boolean equals(Object obj) {
        if (this == obj)
            return true;
        if (obj == null)
            return false;
        if (getClass() != obj.getClass())
            return false;
        Index other = (Index) obj;
        if (x != other.x)
            return false;
        if (y != other.y)
            return false;
        return true;
    }
}

Then have your HashMap<Index, Value> to get your result. :)

Solution 4 - Java

Implemented in common-collections MultiKeyMap

Solution 5 - Java

Two possibilities. Either use a combined key:

class MyKey {
    int firstIndex;
    int secondIndex;
    // important: override hashCode() and equals()
}

Or a Map of Map:

Map<Integer, Map<Integer, Integer>> myMap;

Solution 6 - Java

Use a Pair as keys for the HashMap. JDK has no Pair, but you can either use a 3rd party libraray such as http://commons.apache.org/lang or write a Pair taype of your own.

Solution 7 - Java

Java 7+ contains a new Map.Entry<K,V> class that you can use as key for your map (or entry for your set). It also contains a Map.entry(K k, V v) method to easily create new Map.Entry objects.

Usage:

Map<Map.Entry<Integer,Integer>, Integer> map = new HashMap<>();
map.put(Map.entry(1, 2), 0);

There is also Pair<K, V> in javafx.util

Map<Pair<Integer,Integer>, Integer> map = new HashMap<>();
map.put(new Pair(1, 2), 0);

Solution 8 - Java

Create a value class that will represent your compound key, such as:

class Index2D {
  int first, second;

  // overrides equals and hashCode properly here
}

taking care to override equals() and hashCode() correctly. If that seems like a lot of work, you might consider some ready made generic containers, such as Pair provided by apache commons among others.

There are also many similar questions here, with other ideas, such as using Guava's Table, although allows the keys to have different types, which might be overkill (in memory use and complexity) in your case since I understand your keys are both integers.

Solution 9 - Java

If they are two integers you can try a quick and dirty trick: Map<String, ?> using the key as i+"#"+j.

If the key i+"#"+j is the same as j+"#"+i try min(i,j)+"#"+max(i,j).

Solution 10 - Java

You could create your key object something like this:

public class MapKey {

public  Object key1;
public Object key2;

public Object getKey1() {
    return key1;
}

public void setKey1(Object key1) {
    this.key1 = key1;
}

public Object getKey2() {
    return key2;
}

public void setKey2(Object key2) {
    this.key2 = key2;
}

public boolean equals(Object keyObject){

    if(keyObject==null)
        return false;

    if (keyObject.getClass()!= MapKey.class)
        return false;

    MapKey key = (MapKey)keyObject;

    if(key.key1!=null && this.key1==null)
        return false;

    if(key.key2 !=null && this.key2==null)
        return false;

    if(this.key1==null && key.key1 !=null)
        return false;

    if(this.key2==null && key.key2 !=null)
        return false;

    if(this.key1==null && key.key1==null && this.key2 !=null && key.key2 !=null)
        return this.key2.equals(key.key2);

    if(this.key2==null && key.key2==null && this.key1 !=null && key.key1 !=null)
        return this.key1.equals(key.key1);

    return (this.key1.equals(key.key1) && this.key2.equals(key2));
}

public int hashCode(){
    int key1HashCode=key1.hashCode();
    int key2HashCode=key2.hashCode();
    return key1HashCode >> 3 + key2HashCode << 5;
}

}

The advantage of this is: It will always make sure you are covering all the scenario's of Equals as well.

NOTE: Your key1 and key2 should be immutable. Only then will you be able to construct a stable key Object.

Solution 11 - Java

You can also use guava Table implementation for this.

Table represents a special map where two keys can be specified in combined fashion to refer to a single value. It is similar to creating a map of maps.

//create a table
  Table<String, String, String> employeeTable = HashBasedTable.create();

  //initialize the table with employee details
  employeeTable.put("IBM", "101","Mahesh");
  employeeTable.put("IBM", "102","Ramesh");
  employeeTable.put("IBM", "103","Suresh");

  employeeTable.put("Microsoft", "111","Sohan");
  employeeTable.put("Microsoft", "112","Mohan");
  employeeTable.put("Microsoft", "113","Rohan");

  employeeTable.put("TCS", "121","Ram");
  employeeTable.put("TCS", "122","Shyam");
  employeeTable.put("TCS", "123","Sunil");

  //get Map corresponding to IBM
  Map<String,String> ibmEmployees =  employeeTable.row("IBM");

Solution 12 - Java

we can create a class to pass more than one key or value and the object of this class can be used as a parameter in map.

import java.io.BufferedReader; 
import java.io.FileReader;
import java.io.IOException;
import java.util.*;

 public class key1 {
	String b;
	String a;
	key1(String a,String b)
	{
		this.a=a;
		this.b=b;
	}
  }

public class read2 {

private static final String FILENAME = "E:/studies/JAVA/ReadFile_Project/nn.txt";

public static void main(String[] args) {

	BufferedReader br = null;
	FileReader fr = null;
	Map<key1,String> map=new HashMap<key1,String>();
	try {

		fr = new FileReader(FILENAME);
		br = new BufferedReader(fr);

		String sCurrentLine;

		br = new BufferedReader(new FileReader(FILENAME));

		while ((sCurrentLine = br.readLine()) != null) {
			String[] s1 = sCurrentLine.split(",");
			key1 k1 = new key1(s1[0],s1[2]);
			map.put(k1,s1[2]);
		}
		for(Map.Entry<key1,String> m:map.entrySet()){  
			key1 key = m.getKey();
			String s3 = m.getValue();
			   System.out.println(key.a+","+key.b+" : "+s3);  
			  }  
  //			}	
    	} catch (IOException e) {

		e.printStackTrace();

	} finally {

		try {

			if (br != null)
				br.close();

			if (fr != null)
				fr.close();

		} catch (IOException ex) {

			ex.printStackTrace();

		}

	}

	}

 }

Solution 13 - Java

You can download it from the below link: https://github.com/VVS279/DoubleKeyHashMap/blob/master/src/com/virtualMark/doubleKeyHashMap/DoubleKeyHashMap.java

https://github.com/VVS279/DoubleKeyHashMap

You can use double key: value hashmap,

   DoubleKeyHashMap<Integer, Integer, String> doubleKeyHashMap1 = new 
   DoubleKeyHashMap<Integer, Integer, String>();

   DoubleKeyHashMap<String, String, String> doubleKeyHashMap2 = new 
   DoubleKeyHashMap<String, String, String>();

Solution 14 - Java

Using org.apache.commons.lang3.tuple.Pair is very easy;

   Map<String, Pair<String, Integer>> map= new HashMap<>(); 
   map.put("key", Pair.of("a", 1)); 
   int value = map.get("key").getRight();

Content Type	Original Author	Original Content on Stackoverflow
Question	Crocode	View Question on Stackoverflow
Solution 1 - Java	Tomasz Nurkiewicz	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 2 - Java	chrixle	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 3 - Java	Brad	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 4 - Java	Mike	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 5 - Java	Cyrille Ka	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 6 - Java	MrSmith42	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 7 - Java	Rajat Shah	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 8 - Java	BeeOnRope	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 9 - Java	arutaku	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 10 - Java	Andy	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 11 - Java	slisnychyi	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 12 - Java	Vikas Pal	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 13 - Java	VISHAL SINGH	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 14 - Java	Inanc Cakil	View Answer on Stackoverflow

How to create a HashMap with two keys (Key-Pair, Value)?

Java Problem Overview

Java Solutions

Solution 1 - Java

2 dimensions

Map of maps

Wrapper key object

`Table` from Guava

N dimensions

Solution 2 - Java

Solution 3 - Java

Solution 4 - Java

Solution 5 - Java

Solution 6 - Java

Solution 7 - Java

Solution 8 - Java

Solution 9 - Java

Solution 10 - Java

Solution 11 - Java

Solution 12 - Java

Solution 13 - Java

Solution 14 - Java

Android - Back button in the title bar

How can I change a secret Gist to public?

Attributions

Java Problem Overview

Java Solutions

Solution 1 - Java

2 dimensions

Map of maps

Wrapper key object

Table from Guava

N dimensions

Solution 2 - Java

Solution 3 - Java

Solution 4 - Java

Solution 5 - Java

Solution 6 - Java

Solution 7 - Java

Solution 8 - Java

Solution 9 - Java

Solution 10 - Java

Solution 11 - Java

Solution 12 - Java

Solution 13 - Java

Solution 14 - Java

Android - Back button in the title bar

How can I change a secret Gist to public?

Attributions

`Table` from Guava