git: Apply changes introduced by commit in one repo to another repo
GitGit Problem Overview
I have a repo1
and repo2
on local machine. They are very similar, but the latter is some kind of other branch (repo1
is not maintained anymore).
/path/to/repo1 $ git log HEAD~5..HEAD~4
<some_sha> Add: Introduce feature X
How to apply changes made by commit <some_sha>
in repo1
to repo2
?
Do I need to prepare some patch, or is it possible to do some cherry-pick
between the repos?
How about doing the same but for range of commits?
Git Solutions
Solution 1 - Git
You probably want to use git format-patch
and then git am
to apply that patch to your repository.
/path/to/1 $ git format-patch sha1^..sha1
/path/to/1 $ cd /path/to/2
/path/to/2 $ git am -3 /path/to/1/0001-…-….patch
Or, in one line:
/path/to/2 $ git --git-dir=/path/to/1/.git format-patch --stdout sha1^..sha1 | git am -3
Solution 2 - Git
You can do cherry-pick
if you add the second repo as a remote to the first (and then fetch
).
Solution 3 - Git
As a hack, you can try modifying recipe for comparing commits in two different repositories on GitTips page, i.e.:
GIT_ALTERNATE_OBJECT_DIRECTORIES=../repo/.git/objects \
git cherry-pick $(git --git-dir=../repo/.git rev-parse --verify <commit>)
where ../repo
is path to the other repository.
With modern Git you can use multiple revisions and revision ranges with [cherry-pick][git-cherry-pick].
The $(git --git-dir=../repo/.git rev-parse --verify <commit>)
is here to translate <commit>
(for example HEAD
, or v0.2
, or master~2
, which are values in the second repository you copy from) into SHA-1 identifier of commit. If you know SHA-1 of a change you want to pick, it is not necessary.
NOTE however that Git can skip copying objects from source repository, as it doesn't know that the alternate object repository is only temporary, for one operation. You might need to copy objects from the second repository with:
GIT_ALTERNATE_OBJECT_DIRECTORIES=../repo/.git/objects git repack -a -d -f
This puts those objects borrowed from second repository in original repository storage
Not tested.
A not so hacky solution is to follow knittl answer:
- Go to second repository you want to copy commits from, and generate patches from commits you want with
git format-patch
- Optionally, copy patches (0001-* etc.) to your repository
- Use
git am --3way
to apply patches
[git-cherry-pick]: https://www.kernel.org/pub/software/scm/git/docs/git-cherry-pick.html "git-cherry-pick(1) Manual Page - Apply the changes introduced by some existing commits"
Solution 4 - Git
I wrote a small script for applying the diff output of repo diff https://github.com/raghakh/android-dev-scripts/commit/a57dcba727d271bf2116f981392b0dcbb22734d0