Detect whether scroll event was created by user

Javascript Problem Overview

Is it possible to tell whether a scroll event was done by the browser or by the user? Specifically, when using the back button a browser may jump to the last known scroll position. If I bind to scroll event how can I tell whether this was caused by user or browser?

$(document).scroll( function(){ 
    //who did this?!
});

I see three types of situations that cause scrolling in a browser.

The user performs some action. For example, uses mousewheel, arrow keys, page up/down keys, home/end keys, clicks the scrollbar or drags its thumb.
The browser scrolls automatically. For example, when using the back button in your browser it will jump to the last known scroll position automatically.
Javascript scrolls. For example, element.scrollTo(x,y).

Javascript Solutions

Solution 1 - Javascript

Unfortunately, there is no direct way of telling that.

I would say if you can redesign your app so that it doesn't depend on this type of flow, go for that.

If not, a workaround I can think of is to keep track of user initiated scrolls and check that to see if the scroll was triggered by the browser or by the user.

Here's an example that I put together which does this pretty well (except for browsers where jQuery history has problems with).

You need to run this locally to be able to test it fully (jsFiddle/jsbin are not good fits as they iFrame the contents).

Here's the test cases that I validated:

Page loads - userScroll is false
Scroll using mouse/keyboard - userScroll becomes true
Click on the link to jump to page bottom - userScroll becomes false
Click Back/Forward - userScroll becomes false;

<!DOCTYPE html> 
<html lang="en"> 
<head> 
    <meta charset="utf-8" /> 
    <script src="http://code.jquery.com/jquery-1.6.1.min.js"></script> 
    <script type="text/javascript" src="https://raw.github.com/tkyk/jquery-history-plugin/master/jquery.history.js"></script> 
</head> 
<body> 
    <span> hello there </span><br/> 
    <a href="#bottom"> click here to go down </a> 
    <br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/> 
    <br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/> 
    <br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/> 
    <br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/> 
    <br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/> 
    <br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/> 
    <br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/><br/> 
    <a name="bottom"> just sitting </a> 
</body> 
<script type="text/javascript"> 
 
var userScroll = false;     
 
function mouseEvent(e) { 
    userScroll = true; 
} 
 
 
$(function() { 
 
    // reset flag on back/forward 
    $.history.init(function(hash){ 
        userScroll = false; 
    }); 
 
    $(document).keydown(function(e) { 
        if(e.which == 33        // page up 
           || e.which == 34     // page dn 
           || e.which == 32     // spacebar
           || e.which == 38     // up 
           || e.which == 40     // down 
           || (e.ctrlKey && e.which == 36)     // ctrl + home 
           || (e.ctrlKey && e.which == 35)     // ctrl + end 
          ) { 
            userScroll = true; 
        } 
    }); 
 
    // detect user scroll through mouse
    // Mozilla/Webkit 
    if(window.addEventListener) {
        document.addEventListener('DOMMouseScroll', mouseEvent, false); 
	}
 
    //for IE/OPERA etc 
    document.onmousewheel = mouseEvent; 
	
	
	// to reset flag when named anchors are clicked
	$('a[href*=#]').click(function() { 
		userScroll = false;
	}); 
	
      // detect browser/user scroll
	$(document).scroll( function(){  
		console.log('Scroll initiated by ' + (userScroll == true ? "user" : "browser"));
    });
}); 
</script> 
</html>

Notes:

This doesn't track scrolling when the user drags the scrollbar with mouse. This can be added with some more code, which I left as an exercise for you.
event.keyCodes may vary by OS, so you may have to change that appropriately.

Hope this helps!

Solution 2 - Javascript

Rather than trying to catch all the user events, it's much easier to do the opposite and handle only the programmatic events - and ignore those.

For example, this kind of code would work:

// Element that needs to be scrolled
var myElement = document.getElementById('my-container');

// Flag to tell if the change was programmatic or by the user
var ignoreNextScrollEvent = false;

function setScrollTop(scrollTop) {
	ignoreNextScrollEvent = true;
    myElement.scrollTop = scrollTop
}

myElement.addEventListener('scroll', function() {
	if (ignoreNextScrollEvent) {
        // Ignore this event because it was done programmatically
		ignoreNextScrollEvent = false;
		return;
	}

	// Process user-initiated event here
});

Then when you call setScrollTop(), the scroll event will be ignored, while if the user scroll with the mouse, keyboard or any other way, the event will be processed.

Solution 3 - Javascript

As far as I know it is impossible (without any work) to tell whenever scroll event has been issued by "user" or by other means.

You could try (as others mentioned) catch mousewheel events, then probably trying to catch keydown event on any keys that can trigger scroll (arrows, space etc.) while checking what element is currently focused, since you for example can't scroll using arrow keys while typing in an input field. In general that would be complex and messy script.

Depending on situation you're dealing with you could I guess "revert the logic", and instead of detecting user issued scroll events just hook in into any scrolls made programatically and treat any scroll events not made by your code as made by an user. Like I said it depends on a situation, and what you're trying to achive.

Solution 4 - Javascript

Yes, it is 100% possible. I'm current using this in an application where IE is not a requirement - client facing only. When my Backbone app initiates an animation where scroll is changed - scroll occurs but does not trigger these event captures. This is tested in FF, Safari & Chrome latest.

$('html, body').bind('scroll mousedown wheel DOMMouseScroll mousewheel keyup', function(evt) {
  // detect only user initiated, not by an .animate though
    if (evt.type === 'DOMMouseScroll' || evt.type === 'keyup' || evt.type === 'mousewheel') {
    // up
    if (evt.originalEvent.detail < 0 || (evt.originalEvent.wheelDelta && evt.originalEvent.wheelDelta > 0)) { 
    // down.
    } else if (evt.originalEvent.detail > 0 || (evt.originalEvent.wheelDelta && evt.originalEvent.wheelDelta < 0)) { 
  }
}
});

Solution 5 - Javascript

Try using the Mousewheel and DOMMouseScroll events instead. See http://www.quirksmode.org/dom/events/scroll.html

Solution 6 - Javascript

You can check the scroll position on ready. When you fire the on scroll event check to make sure the scroll position is different than it was when the page loaded. Lastly be sure to clear out the stored value once the page is scrolled.

$(function () {
	var loadScrollTop = ($(document).scrollTop() > 0 ? $(document).scrollTop() : null);
	$(document).scroll(function (e) {
		if ( $(document).scrollTop() !== loadScrollTop) {
			// scroll code here!
		}
		loadScrollTop = null;
	});
});

Solution 7 - Javascript

There is one more way to separate the user-created scroll: you can use the alternative event handlers, for example 'mousewheel', 'touchmove', 'keydown' with codes 38 and 40 for arrow scrolling, for scrolling with scroll bar - if 'scroll' event is fired simultaneously with 'mousedown' until 'mouseup' event.

Solution 8 - Javascript

Regarding to:

> Specifically, when using the back button a browser may jump to the last known scroll position.

That fires very soon, after the page is rendered. You can just delay listenting to the scroll event by 1 second or so.

Solution 9 - Javascript

Found this very useful. Here's a coffeescript version for those so inclined.

$ ->
  S.userScroll = false

  # reset flag on back/forward
  if $.history?
    $.history.init (hash) ->
      S.userScroll = false

  mouseEvent = (e)->
    S.userScroll = true

  $(document).keydown (e) ->
    importantKey =  (e.which == 33 or        # page up
      e.which == 34 or    # page dn
      e.which == 32 or    # spacebar
      e.which == 38 or    # up
      e.which == 40 or    # down
      (e.ctrlKey and e.which == 36) or    # ctrl + home
      (e.ctrlKey and e.which == 35)    # ctrl + end
    )
    if importantKey
      S.userScroll = true;

  # Detect user scroll through mouse
  # Mozilla/Webkit
  if window.addEventListener
      document.addEventListener('DOMMouseScroll', mouseEvent, false);

  # for IE/OPERA etc
  document.onmousewheel = mouseEvent;

Solution 10 - Javascript

if you're using JQuery than there's a better answer, apparently - i'm just trying it out myself.

see: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/11049287/detect-jquery-event-trigger-by-user-or-call-by-code

Solution 11 - Javascript

It might not help with your application, but I needed to fire an event on user scroll but not programatic scroll and posting incase it helps anyone else.

Listen to the wheel event instead of scroll,

It is triggered whenever a user uses the mouse wheel or tracker pad( which I feel is how most people scroll anyway) and isn't fired when you programatically scroll. I used it to differentiate between a user scroll action and scrolling functions.

https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/Element/wheel_event


element.addEventListener('wheel', (event) => {
       //do user scroll stuff here
})

One caveat is that wheel doesn't fire on scroll on mobile, so I checked whether the device was mobile and used similar functions

if(this.mobile){
  element.addEventListener('scroll', (event) => {
       //do mobile scroll stuff here
  })
}

Content Type	Original Author	Original Content on Stackoverflow
Question	mrtsherman	View Question on Stackoverflow
Solution 1 - Javascript	Mrchief	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 2 - Javascript	laurent	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 3 - Javascript	WTK	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 4 - Javascript	user1248475	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 5 - Javascript	Gerben	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 6 - Javascript	Rusty Jeans	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 7 - Javascript	Alex Kuzmin	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 8 - Javascript	Firsh - justifiedgrid.com	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 9 - Javascript	nottombrown	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 10 - Javascript	nathan g	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 11 - Javascript	TimothyBuktu	View Answer on Stackoverflow