Check if cookies are enabled

Php Problem Overview

I am working on a page that requires javascript and sessions. I already have code to warn the user if javascript is disabled. Now, I want to handle the case where cookies are disabled, as the session id is stored in cookies.

I have thought of just a couple ideas:

Embedding the session id in the links and forms
Warn the user they must enable cookies if they are disabled (would need help detecting if cookies are disabled)

What is the best way to approach this? Thanks

EDIT

Based on the articles linked, I came up with my own approach and thought I would share, somebody else might be able to use it, maybe I will get a few critiques. (Assumes your PHP session stores in a cookie named PHPSESSID)

<div id="form" style="display:none">Content goes here</div>
<noscript>Sorry, but Javascript is required</noscript>
<script type="text/javascript"><!--
if(document.cookie.indexOf('PHPSESSID')!=-1)
   document.getElementById('form').style.display='';
else
   document.write('<p>Sorry, but cookies must be enabled</p>');
--></script>

Php Solutions

Solution 1 - Php

JavaScript

In JavaScript you simple test for the cookieEnabled property, which is supported in all major browsers. If you deal with an older browser, you can set a cookie and check if it exists. (borrowed from Modernizer):

if (navigator.cookieEnabled) return true;

// set and read cookie
document.cookie = "cookietest=1";
var ret = document.cookie.indexOf("cookietest=") != -1;

// delete cookie
document.cookie = "cookietest=1; expires=Thu, 01-Jan-1970 00:00:01 GMT";

return ret;

PHP

In PHP it is rather "complicated" since you have to refresh the page or redirect to another script. Here I will use two scripts:

somescript.php

<?php
session_start();
setcookie('foo', 'bar', time()+3600);
header("location: check.php");

check.php

<?php echo (isset($_COOKIE['foo']) && $_COOKIE['foo']=='bar') ? 'enabled' : 'disabled';

Detecting if the cookies are enabled with PHP
~~PHP and Cookies, A Good Mix!~~

Solution 2 - Php

But to check whether cookies are enabled using isset($_COOKIE["cookie"]) you have to refresh. Im doing it ths way (with sessions based on cookies :)

session_start();
$a = session_id();
session_destroy();

session_start();
$b = session_id();
session_destroy();

if ($a == $b)
	echo"Cookies ON";
else
	echo"Cookies OFF";

Solution 3 - Php

Answer on an old question, this new post is posted on April the 4th 2013

To complete the answer of @misza, here a advanced method to check if cookies are enabled without page reloading. The problem with @misza is that it not always work when the php ini setting session.use_cookies is not true. Also the solution does not check if a session is already started.

I made this function and test it many times with in different situations and does the job very well.

    function suGetClientCookiesEnabled() // Test if browser has cookies enabled
    {
      // Avoid overhead, if already tested, return it
      if( defined( 'SU_CLIENT_COOKIES_ENABLED' ))
       { return SU_CLIENT_COOKIES_ENABLED; }
       
      $bIni = ini_get( 'session.use_cookies' ); 
      ini_set( 'session.use_cookies', 1 ); 
      
      $a = session_id();
      $bWasStarted = ( is_string( $a ) && strlen( $a ));
      if( !$bWasStarted )
      {
    	@session_start();
    	$a = session_id();
      }
      
   // Make a copy of current session data
  $aSesDat = (isset( $_SESSION ))?$_SESSION:array();
   // Now we destroy the session and we lost the data but not the session id 
   // when cookies are enabled. We restore the data later. 
  @session_destroy(); 
   // Restart it
  @session_start();
   
   // Restore copy
  $_SESSION = $aSesDat;
  		
   // If no cookies are enabled, the session differs from first session start
  $b = session_id();
  if( !$bWasStarted )
   { // If not was started, write data to the session container to avoid data loss
     @session_write_close(); 
   }
   
   // When no cookies are enabled, $a and $b are not the same
  $b = ($a === $b);
  define( 'SU_CLIENT_COOKIES_ENABLED', $b );
  
  if( !$bIni )
   { @ini_set( 'session.use_cookies', 0 ); }
  
  //echo $b?'1':'0';
  return $b;
    }

Usage:

if( suGetClientCookiesEnabled())
 { echo 'Cookies are enabled!'; }
else { echo 'Cookies are NOT enabled!'; }

Important note: The function temporarily modify the ini setting of PHP when it not has the correct setting and restore it when it was not enabled. This is only to test if cookies are enabled. It can get go wrong when you start a session and the php ini setting session.use_cookies has an incorrect value. To be sure that the session is working correctly, check and/or set it before start a session, for example:

   if( suGetClientCookiesEnabled())
     { 
       echo 'Cookies are enabled!'; 
       ini_set( 'session.use_cookies', 1 ); 
       echo 'Starting session';
       @start_session(); 

     }
    else { echo 'Cookies are NOT enabled!'; }

Solution 4 - Php

A transparent, clean and simple approach, checking cookies availability with PHP and taking advantage of AJAX transparent redirection, hence not triggering a page reload. It doesn't require sessions either.

Client-side code (JavaScript)

function showCookiesMessage(cookiesEnabled) {
    if (cookiesEnabled == 'true')
        alert('Cookies enabled');
    else
        alert('Cookies disabled');
}

$(document).ready(function() {
    var jqxhr = $.get('/cookiesEnabled.php');
    jqxhr.done(showCookiesMessage);
});

(JQuery AJAX call can be replaced with pure JavaScript AJAX call)

Server-side code (PHP)

if (isset($_COOKIE['cookieCheck'])) {
    echo 'true';
} else {
    if (isset($_GET['reload'])) {
        echo 'false';
    } else {
        setcookie('cookieCheck', '1', time() + 60);
        header('Location: ' . $_SERVER['PHP_SELF'] . '?reload');
        exit();
    }
}

First time the script is called, the cookie is set and the script tells the browser to redirect to itself. The browser does it transparently. No page reload takes place because it's done within an AJAX call scope.

The second time, when called by redirection, if the cookie is received, the script responds an HTTP 200 (with string "true"), hence the showCookiesMessage function is called.

If the script is called for the second time (identified by the "reload" parameter) and the cookie is not received, it responds an HTTP 200 with string "false" -and the showCookiesMessage function gets called.

Solution 5 - Php

You cannot in the same page's loading set and check if cookies is set you must perform reload page:

PHP run at Server;
cookies at client.
cookies sent to server only during loading of a page.
Just created cookies have not been sent to server yet and will be sent only at next load of the page.

Solution 6 - Php

You can make an Ajax Call (Note: This solution requires JQuery):

example.php

<?php
    setcookie('CookieEnabledTest', 'check', time()+3600);
?>

<script type="text/javascript">
    
    CookieCheck();
    
    function CookieCheck()
    {
        $.post
        (
            'ajax.php',
            {
                cmd: 'cookieCheck'
            },
            function (returned_data, status)
            {
                if (status === "success")
                {
                    if (returned_data === "enabled")
                    {
                        alert ("Cookies are activated.");
                    }
                    else
                    {
                        alert ("Cookies are not activated.");
                    }
                }
            }
        );
    }
</script>

ajax.php

$cmd = filter_input(INPUT_POST, "cmd");

if ( isset( $cmd ) && $cmd == "cookieCheck" )
{
    echo (isset($_COOKIE['CookieEnabledTest']) && $_COOKIE['CookieEnabledTest']=='check') ? 'enabled' : 'disabled';
}

As result an alert box appears which shows wheter cookies are enabled or not. Of course you don't have to show an alert box, from here you can take other steps to deal with deactivated cookies.

Solution 7 - Php

JavaScript

You could create a cookie using JavaScript and check if it exists:

//Set a Cookie`
document.cookie="testcookie"`

//Check if cookie exists`
cookiesEnabled=(document.cookie.indexOf("testcookie")!=-1)? true : false`

Or you could use a http://www.webmuse.co.uk/projects/jcookie-jquery-plugin/">jQuery Cookie plugin

//Set a Cookie`
$.cookie("testcookie", "testvalue")

//Check if cookie exists`
cookiesEnabled=( $.cookie("testcookie") ) ? true : false`

Php

setcookie("testcookie", "testvalue");

if( isset( $_COOKIE['testcookie'] ) ) {

}

Not sure if the Php will work as I'm unable to test it.

Solution 8 - Php

it is easy to detect whether the cookies is enabled:

set a cookie.
get the cookie

if you can get the cookie you set, the cookie is enabled, otherwise not.

BTW: it is a bad idea to Embedding the session id in the links and forms, it is bad for SEO. In my opinion, it is not very common that people dont want to enable cookies.

Solution 9 - Php

Here is a very useful and lightweight javascript plugin to accomplish this: js-cookie

Cookies.set('cookieName', 'Value');
      setTimeout(function(){
        var cookieValue =  Cookies.get('cookieName');
        if(cookieValue){
           console.log("Test Cookie is set!");
        } else {
           document.write('<p>Sorry, but cookies must be enabled</p>');
        }
        Cookies.remove('cookieName');
      }, 1000);

Works in all browsers, accepts any character.

Solution 10 - Php

Cookies are Client-side and cannot be tested properly using PHP. That's the baseline and every solution is a wrap-around for this problem.

Meaning if you are looking a solution for your cookie problem, you are on the wrong way. Don'y use PHP, use a client language like Javascript.

Can you use cookies using PHP? Yes, but you have to reload to make the settings to PHP 'visible'.

For instance: Is a test possible to see if the browser can set Cookies with plain PHP'. The only correct answer is 'NO'.

Can you read an already set Cookie: 'YES' use the predefined $_COOKIE (A copy of the settings before you started PHP-App).

Content Type	Original Author	Original Content on Stackoverflow
Question	steveo225	View Question on Stackoverflow
Solution 1 - Php	Sascha Galley	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 2 - Php	misza	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 3 - Php	Codebeat	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 4 - Php	zibilico	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 5 - Php	drfunjohn	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 6 - Php	Black	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 7 - Php	Tomgrohl	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 8 - Php	James.Xu	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 9 - Php	Grant	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 10 - Php	Harm	View Answer on Stackoverflow