Why there are no concurrency keywords in Kotlin?

JavaConcurrencyKotlin

Java Problem Overview


Why there are no keywords for synchronization/concurrency?

So far my research gives me one solution, you wrap some high level classes and use them to handle concurrency.

Given a project in pure Kotlin, what one shall do if there is a need for a small highly optimized component that handles concurrency etc?

My impression is that Kotlin is an assisting language for Java, to write 90% of the code in Kotlin but have some java code that is not possible to express with Kotlin.

Is this right? Is this how it was intended to be?

Java Solutions


Solution 1 - Java

Kotlin 1.1 with Coroutines was released and it brings with it async..await! Read more about it in Kotlin reference docs, Kotlinx Coroutines library and this great in depth Couroutines by Example

Outside of the Kotlin Coroutines, you have these options:

You have everything Java has and more. Your phrase "synchronization and locks" is satisfied by the list above, and then you have even more and without language changes. Any language features would only make it a bit prettier.

So you can have 100% Kotlin code, using the small Kotlin runtime, the JVM runtime from the JDK, and any other JVM library you want to use. No need for Java code, just Java (as-in JVM) libraries.

A quick sample of some features:

class SomethingSyncd {
    @Synchronized fun syncFoo() {
        
    }
    
    val myLock = Any()
    
    fun foo() {
        synchronized(myLock) {
            // ... code
        }
    }
    
    @Volatile var thing = mapOf(...)
}

Solution 2 - Java

I'll answer my own question since actual answer to my question was somewhere deep in kotlin discussions.

What confused me at the time coming from Java was that concurrency keywords were not language keywords they were annotations? to me it seemed strange that important concepts like synchronization were handled through annotations, but now it makes perfect sense. Kotlin is going in the direction of being a platform agnostic language, it's not going to only work on JVM but pretty much anything. So synchronized and volatile were very specific to JVM, they might not be needed in javascript for example.

In a nutshell Kotlin has everything Java has (except package visibility) and much more, a huge difference that no other language has is coroutines. But there is nothing you can write in Java that you cant do in Kotlin... (as far as I am aware)

Attributions

All content for this solution is sourced from the original question on Stackoverflow.

The content on this page is licensed under the Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International (CC BY-SA 4.0) license.

Content TypeOriginal AuthorOriginal Content on Stackoverflow
QuestionvachView Question on Stackoverflow
Solution 1 - JavaJayson MinardView Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 2 - JavavachView Answer on Stackoverflow