When should one use Theme.AppCompat vs ThemeOverlay.AppCompat?

There are the following Theme.AppCompat classes:

Theme.AppCompat
Theme.AppCompat.Light
Theme.AppCompat.Light.DarkActionBar
Theme.AppCompat.NoActionBar
Theme.AppCompat.Light.NoActionBar
Theme.AppCompat.DialogWhenLarge
Theme.AppCompat.Light.DialogWhenLarge
Theme.AppCompat.Dialog
Theme.AppCompat.Light.Dialog
Theme.AppCompat.CompactMenu

and the following ThemeOverlay.AppCompat classes:

ThemeOverlay.AppCompat
ThemeOverlay.AppCompat.Light
ThemeOverlay.AppCompat.Dark
ThemeOverlay.AppCompat.ActionBar
ThemeOverlay.AppCompat.Dark.ActionBar

Why would one use ThemeOverlay.AppCompat.light vs Theme.AppCompat.Light for example? I see that there are much less attributes defined for ThemeOverlay -- I am curious what the intended use case for ThemeOverlay is.

Theme.AppCompat is used to set the global theme for the entire app. ThemeOverlay.AppCompat is used to override (or "overlay") that theme for specific views, especially the Toolbar.

Let's look at an example for why this is necessary.

#App themes with an ActionBar

The ActionBar is normally shown in an app. I can choose it's color by setting the colorPrimary value. However, changing the theme changes the color of the text on the ActionBar.

<style name="AppTheme" parent="Theme.AppCompat">
    <item name="colorPrimary">@color/colorPrimary</item>
    <item name="colorPrimaryDark">@color/colorPrimaryDark</item>
    <item name="colorAccent">@color/colorAccent</item>
</style>

Since my primary color is dark blue, I should probably use one of the themes that uses a light text color in the action bar because the black text is hard to read.

#Hiding the ActionBar and using a Toolbar

The whole point of using Theme.AppCompat rather than Theme.Material is so that we can allow older versions of Android to use our material design theme. The problem is that older versions of Android don't support the ActionBar. Thus, the documentation recommends hiding the ActionBar and adding a Toolbar to your layout. To hide the ActionBar we have to use one of the NoActionBar themes. The following images show the Toolbar with the ActionBar hidden.

But what if I want something like a Light theme with a DarkActionBar? Since I have to use NoActionBar, that isn't an option.

#Overriding the App Theme

Here is where ThemeOverlay comes in. I can specify the Dark ActionBar theme in my Toolbar xml layout.

<android.support.v7.widget.Toolbar
    ...
    android:background="?attr/colorPrimary"
    android:theme="@style/ThemeOverlay.AppCompat.Dark.ActionBar" />

This finally allows us to have the effect we want. The Dark.ActionBar theme overlays the Light app theme for this particular occasion.

• App Theme: Theme.AppCompat.Light.NoActionBar
• Toolbar Theme: ThemeOverlay.AppCompat.Dark.ActionBar

If you wanted the popup menu to be light you could add this:

app:popupTheme="@style/ThemeOverlay.AppCompat.Light"

#Further Study

I learned this through experimentation and through reading the following articles.

• Setting Up the App Bar

• Use android:theme and ThemeOverlay to theme specific Views and their descendents

• Theming with AppCompat

• Use colorPrimary to colorize your App Bar

• Theme vs Style

Per this Theme vs Style blog post by the creator of AppCompat:

> [ThemeOverlays] are special themes which overlay the normal Theme.Material themes, overwriting relevant attributes to make them either light/dark.

> ThemeOverlay + ActionBar

> The keen eyed of you will also have seen the ActionBar ThemeOverlay derivatives:

> - ThemeOverlay.Material.Light.ActionBar > - ThemeOverlay.Material.Dark.ActionBar

> These should only be used with the Action Bar via the new actionBarTheme attribute, or directly set on your Toolbar.

> The only things these currently do differently to their parents is that they change the colorControlNormal to be android:textColorPrimary, thus making any text and icons opaque.