What is the purpose of Verifiable() in Moq?

Moq

Moq Problem Overview


What is the purpose of Verifiable()?

If I verify a Mock and leave this out it still verifies the SetUp.

Edit: I was using VerifyAll() thus the reason for everything being verified. After changing to Verify() only my .Verifiable() SetUps were being checked.

Moq Solutions


Solution 1 - Moq

ADDENDUM: As the other answer states, the purpose of .Verifiable is to enlist a Setup into a set of "deferred Verify(...) calls" which can then be triggered via mock.Verify().

The OP's clarification makes it clear that this was the goal and the only problem was figuring out why it wasn't working, but as @Liam prodded, the answer should really touch on this too:- The key use cases as far as I can see are:

  • maintaining DRYness between a mock.Setup() and mock.Verify
  • allowing one to disconnect the configuring of a verification from the actual Verify call itself (e.g., you could set it up in another helper method)

... and back to my answer, which tersely effectively says "be careful as the above pros are commonly considered to be outweighed by the effect that achieving those goals has on the legibility and maintainability of tests which lean too much on such constructs"

ORIGINAL: Note that where possible, one should instead follow the AAA layout and hence one should be doing explicit mock.Verify( expression ) calls after the work has been done, rather than a mock.Setup( ... ).Verifiable() paired with a mock.Verify() or mock.VerifyAll() wherever possible (credit: @kzu).

Solution 2 - Moq

When the Verify() method is called at the end of the test, if any of the expectations marked as verifiable have not been called, then an exception is thrown.

VerifyAll() does not check for verifiable expectations.

Attributions

All content for this solution is sourced from the original question on Stackoverflow.

The content on this page is licensed under the Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International (CC BY-SA 4.0) license.

Content TypeOriginal AuthorOriginal Content on Stackoverflow
QuestionCastrohengeView Question on Stackoverflow
Solution 1 - MoqRuben BartelinkView Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 2 - MoqSuPraView Answer on Stackoverflow