What are the differences between final class and sealed class in Scala?
ScalaAccess ModifiersScala Problem Overview
There are two types of modifiers in Scala: final
and sealed
What are the differences between them? When should you use one over the other?
Scala Solutions
Solution 1 - Scala
A final
class cannot be extended, period.
A sealed
trait can only be extended in the same source file as it's declared. This is useful for creating ADTs (algebraic data types). An ADT is defined by the sum of its derived types.
E.g.:
- An
Option[A]
is defined bySome[A]
+None
. - A
List[A]
is defined by::
+Nil
.
sealed trait Option[+A]
final case class Some[+A] extends Option[A]
object None extends Option[Nothing]
Because Option[A]
is sealed, it cannot be extended by other developers - doing so would alter its meaning.
Some[A]
is final because it cannot be extended, period.
As an added bonus, if a trait is sealed, the compiler can warn you if your pattern matches are not exhaustive enough because it knows that Option
is limited to Some
and None
.
opt match {
case Some(a) => "hello"
}
> Warning: match may not be exhaustive. It would fail on the following input: None
Solution 2 - Scala
sealed
classes (or traits) can still be inherited in the same source file (where final
classes can't be inherited at all).
Use sealed
when you want to restrict the number of subclasses of a base class (see "Algebraic Data Type").
As one of the very practical benefits of such a restriction the compiler can now warn you about non-exaustive pattern matches:
sealed trait Duo
case class One(i:Int) extends Duo
case class Two(i:Int, j:Int) extends Duo
def test(d:Duo) {
match {
case One(x) => println(x) // warning since you are not matching Two
}
}