Using Git how do I find changes between local and remote
GitMercurialGit Problem Overview
Here are two different questions but I think they are related.
-
When using Git, how do I find which changes I have committed locally, but haven't yet pushed to a remote branch? I'm looking for something similar to the Mercurial command
hg outgoing
. -
When using Git, how do I find what changes a remote branch has prior to doing a pull? I'm looking for something similar to the Mercurial command
hg incoming
.
For the second: is there a way to see what is available and then cherry-pick the changes I want to pull?
Git Solutions
Solution 1 - Git
Starting with Git 1.7.0, there is a special syntax that allows you to generically refer to the upstream branch: @{u}
or @{upstream}
.
To mimic hg incoming
:
git log ..@{u}
To mimic hg outgoing
:
git log @{u}..
I use the following incoming
and outgoing
aliases to make the above easier to use:
git config --global alias.incoming '!git remote update -p; git log ..@{u}'
git config --global alias.outgoing 'log @{u}..'
Solution 2 - Git
Git can't send that kind of information over the network, like Hg can. But you can run git fetch
(which is more like hg pull
than hg fetch
) to fetch new commits from your remote servers.
So, if you have a branch called master
and a remote called origin
, after running git fetch
, you should also have a branch called origin/master
. You can then get the git log
of all commits that master
needs to be a superset of origin/master
by doing git log master..origin/master
. Invert those two to get the opposite.
A friend of mine, David Dollar, has created a couple of git shell scripts to simulate hg incoming/outgoing
. You can find them at http://github.com/ddollar/git-utils.
Solution 3 - Git
Not a full answer but git fetch will pull the remote repo and not do a merge. You can then do a
git diff master origin/master
Solution 4 - Git
-
Use "git log origin..HEAD"
-
Use "git fetch" followed by "git log HEAD..origin". You can cherry-pick individual commits using the listed commit ids.
The above assumes, of course, that "origin" is the name of your remote tracking branch (which it is if you've used clone with default options).
Solution 5 - Git
There's also this, for comparing all branches:
git log --branches --not --remotes=origin
This is what the git log man page says about this:
> Shows all commits that are in any of > local branches but not in any of > remote tracking branches for origin > (what you have that origin doesn’t).
The above is for outgoing
.
For incoming
, just swap:
git log --remotes=origin --not --branches
Solution 6 - Git
I would do
$ git fetch --dry-run
for hg incoming
and
$ git push --dry-run
for hg outgoing
.
Solution 7 - Git
git-out is a script that emulates hg outgoing
quite accurately. It parses on "push -n" output, so it produces accurate output if you need to specify additional arguments to push.
Solution 8 - Git
git incoming
$ git fetch && git log ..origin/master --stat
OR
$ git fetch && git log ..origin/master --patch
git outgoing
$ git fetch && git log origin/master.. --stat
OR
$ git fetch && git log origin/master.. --patch
Solution 9 - Git
When the "git log" and @{u} answers initially gave me "unknown revision" errors, I tried out Chris/romkyns suggestion of git push --dry-run
.
You will get an output such as "5905..4878 master->master". 5905 is the latest commit that the remote has and commits through (and including) 4878 will be applied to the remote.
You can then use 5905..4878 as arguments to several other git commands to get more details:
git diff 5905..4878 # Gives full code changes in diff style
git log --online 5905..4878 # Displays each commit's comment
Solution 10 - Git
Incoming commits across all branches can be shown with the following approach.
The command git fetch-diff
becomes available by adding an executable called git-fetch-diff
to your PATH, containing:
#!/bin/bash
set -e
# get hashes before fetch
old_hashes=$(git log --all --no-color --pretty=format:"%H")
# perform the fetch
git fetch
# get hashes after fetch
new_hashes=$(git log --all --no-color --pretty=format:"%H")
# get the difference
added_hashes=$(comm -1 -3 <(echo "$old_hashes") <(echo "$new_hashes"))
# print added hashes
[ ! -z "$added_hashes" ] && echo "$added_hashes" | git log --stdin --no-walk --oneline
Commit hashes are compared before and after the fetch. The difference is piped back to git log
for pretty printing. The appearance of the printed log can be further tuned to your liking with arguments such as --pretty=<format>
and --graph
.
Note: You might want to cap how far git log
will go back in time depending on how much a bash variable can hold on your system, or for performance reasons. This can be done by adding the argument --max-count=<count>
.
Solution 11 - Git
When you do git fetch, all the contents including branches,tags ( refs) are stored temporarily in .git/FETCH_HEAD whose content can be viewed with command: git log FETCH_HEAD If you don't use suffix -a with git fetch then by default, FETCH_HEAD's content's will be overwritten by new contents. From these contents, you can view and decide to which branch you want to merge them if you do or you can simple cherry-pick if you want only a few commits from what has been brought by fetch.