Streaming via RTSP or RTP in HTML5

VideoHtmlStreamingRtspRtp

Video Problem Overview


I'm building a web app that should play back an RTSP/RTP stream from a server http://lscube.org/projects/feng</strike>;.

Does the HTML5 video/audio tag support the rtsp or rtp? If not, what would the easiest solution be? Perhaps drop down to a VLC plugin or something like that.

Video Solutions


Solution 1 - Video

Technically 'Yes'

(but not really...)

HTML 5's <video> tag is protocol agnostic—it does not care. You place the protocol in the src attribute as part of the URL. E.g.:

<video src="rtp://myserver.com/path/to/stream">
    Your browser does not support the VIDEO tag and/or RTP streams.
</video>

or maybe

<video src="http://myserver.com:1935/path/to/stream/myPlaylist.m3u8">
    Your browser does not support the VIDEO tag and/or RTP streams.
</video>

That said, the implementation of the <video> tag is browser specific. Since it is early days for HTML 5, I expect frequently changing support (or lack of support).

From the W3C's HTML5 spec (The video element):

>User agents may support any video and audio codecs and container formats

Solution 2 - Video

The spirit of the question, I think, was not truly answered. No, you cannot use a video tag to play rtsp streams as of now. The other answer regarding the link to Chromium guy's "never" is a bit misleading as the linked thread / answer is not directly referring to Chrome playing rtsp via the video tag. Read the entire linked thread, especially the comments at the very bottom and links to other threads.

The real answer is this: No, you cannot just put a video tag on an html 5 page and play rtsp. You need to use a Javascript library of some sort (unless you want to get into playing things with flash and silverlight players) to play streaming video. {IMHO} At the rate the html 5 video discussion and implementation is going, the various vendors of proprietary video standards are not interested in helping this move forward so don't count of the promised ease of use of the video tag unless the browser makers take it upon themselves to somehow solve the problem...again, not likely.{/IMHO}

Solution 3 - Video

This is an old qustion, but I had to do it myself recently and I achieved something working so (besides response like mine would save me some time): Basically use ffmpeg to change the container to HLS, most of the IPCams stream h264 and some basic type of PCM, so use something like that:

ffmpeg -v info -i rtsp://ip:port/h264.sdp -c:v copy -c:a copy -bufsize 1835k -pix_fmt yuv420p -flags -global_header -hls_time 10 -hls_list_size 6 -hls_wrap 10 -start_number 1 /var/www/html/test.m3u8

Then use video.js with HLS plugin This will play Live stream nicely There is also a jsfiddle example under second link).

Note: although this is not a native support it doesn't require anything extra on user frontend.

Solution 4 - Video

There are three streaming protocols / technology in HTML5:

Live streaming, low latency

  • WebRTC
  • Websocket

VOD and Live streaming, high latency

  • HLS

1. WebRTC

In fact WebRTC is SRTP(secure RTP protocol). Thus we can say that video tag supports RTP(SRTP) indirectly via WebRTC.

Therefore to get RTP stream on your Chrome, Firefox or another HTML5 browser, you need a WebRTC server which will deliver the SRTP stream to browser.

2. Websocket

It is TCP based, but with lower latency than HLS. Again you need a Websocket server.

3. HLS

Most popular high-latency streaming protocol for VOD(pre-recorded video).

Solution 5 - Video

Chrome will never implement support RTSP streaming.

At least, in the words of a Chromium developer here:

> we're never going to add support for this

Solution 6 - Video

With VLC i'm able to transcode a live RTSP stream (mpeg4) to an HTTP stream in a OGG format (Vorbis/Theora). The quality is poor but the video work in Chrome 9. I have also tested with a trancoding in WEBM (VP8) but it's don't seem to work (VLC have the option but i don't know if it's really implemented for now..)

The first to have a doc on this should notify us ;)

Solution 7 - Video

Chrome not implement support RTSP streaming. An important project to check it WebRTC.

"WebRTC is a free, open project that provides browsers and mobile applications with Real-Time Communications (RTC) capabilities via simple APIs"

Supported Browsers:

Chrome, Firefox and Opera.

Supported Mobile Platforms:

Android and IOS

http://www.webrtc.org/

Solution 8 - Video

My observations regarding the HTML 5 video tag and rtsp(rtp) streams are, that it only works with konqueror(KDE 4.4.1, Phonon-backend set to GStreamer). I got only video (no audio) with a H.264/AAC RTSP(RTP) stream.

The streams from http://media.esof2010.org/ didn't work with konqueror(KDE 4.4.1, Phonon-backend set to GStreamer).

Solution 9 - Video

Putting a conclusion as of now.

I am trying to build a way around it meaninglessly since rtsp doesn't work OOB. Without a "manager" handling the streaming to be perfected to the way a video tag works, it's not possible now.

I am currently working on something around android+html (hybrid) solution to manage this in a very wicked way. Since it is supposed to play directly from camera to android with no intermediary servers, we came up with a solution involving canvas tag to bridge the non-webview with the webview.

Solution 10 - Video

Years past, there are some updates about RTSP in H5:

  • RTSP is not supported in H5, neither PC nor mobile.
  • Flash is disabled in Chrome, see Adobe
  • MSE works good except iOS safari, for flv.js to play HTTP-FLV on H5, or hls.js to play HLS on H5.
  • WebRTC is also a possible way to play streaming in H5, especially in 0.2~1s latency scenarios.

> Note: I think it's because RTSP use TCP signaling protocol to exchange SDP, which is not HTTP in H5 so it's really hard to support it, especially there is WebRTC now.

So, if you could transcode RTSP to other protocols, like HTTP-FLV/HLS/WebRTC, then you could use H5 to play the stream. Recommend to use FFmpeg to do the transcode:

ffmpeg -i "rtsp://user:password@ip" -c:v libx264 -f flv rtmp://server/live/stream

Start a RTMP server like SRS to accept the RTMP and transmux to HTTP-FLV, HLS and WebRTC:

./objs/srs -c conf/rtmp2rtc.conf

Then it's OK to play the stream by:

  • HLS by video or hls.js: http://server:8080/live/stream.m3u8
  • HTTP-FLV by flv.js: http://server:8080/live/stream.flv
  • WebRTC by H5 or native SDK: webrtc://server:1985/live/stream

Note that the latency of HLS is about 510s, LLHLS is better but not too much. The HTTP-FLV is about 13s, very similar to RTMP. And the WebRTC latency is about 0.2s, while if covert RTSP to RTMP to WebRTC the latency is about 0.8s.

Attributions

All content for this solution is sourced from the original question on Stackoverflow.

The content on this page is licensed under the Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International (CC BY-SA 4.0) license.

Content TypeOriginal AuthorOriginal Content on Stackoverflow
QuestionElben ShiraView Question on Stackoverflow
Solution 1 - VideoStu ThompsonView Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 2 - VideoGolfARamaView Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 3 - VideoPawel KView Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 4 - VideoankitrView Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 5 - VideojanesconferenceView Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 6 - VideomolokolocoView Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 7 - VideovrbsmView Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 8 - VideoRenegah View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 9 - VideoHimadhar HView Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 10 - VideoWinlinView Answer on Stackoverflow