Separating class code into a header and cpp file

C++OopClass

C++ Problem Overview


I am confused on how to separate implementation and declarations code of a simple class into a new header and cpp file. For example, how would I separate the code for the following class?

class A2DD
{
  private:
  int gx;
  int gy;

  public:
  A2DD(int x,int y)
  {
	gx = x;
	gy = y;
  }

  int getSum()
  {
	return gx + gy;
  }
};

C++ Solutions


Solution 1 - C++

The class declaration goes into the header file. It is important that you add the #ifndef include guards. Most compilers now also support #pragma once. Also I have omitted the private, by default C++ class members are private.

// A2DD.h
#ifndef A2DD_H
#define A2DD_H

class A2DD
{
  int gx;
  int gy;

public:
  A2DD(int x,int y);
  int getSum();

};

#endif

and the implementation goes in the CPP file:

// A2DD.cpp
#include "A2DD.h"

A2DD::A2DD(int x,int y)
{
  gx = x;
  gy = y;
}

int A2DD::getSum()
{
  return gx + gy;
}

 

Solution 2 - C++

In general your .h contains the class defition, which is all your data and all your method declarations. Like this in your case:

A2DD.h:

class A2DD
{
  private:
  int gx;
  int gy;

  public:
  A2DD(int x,int y);    
  int getSum();
};

And then your .cpp contains the implementations of the methods like this:

A2DD.cpp:

A2DD::A2DD(int x,int y)
{
  gx = x;
  gy = y;
}

int A2DD::getSum()
{
  return gx + gy;
}

Solution 3 - C++

It's important to point out to readers stumbling upon this question when researching the subject in a broader fashion that the accepted answer's procedure is not required in the case you just want to split your project into files. It's only needed when you need multiple implementations of single classes. If your implementation per class is one, just one header file for each is enough.

Hence, from the accepted answer's example only this part is needed:

#ifndef MYHEADER_H
#define MYHEADER_H

//Class goes here, full declaration AND implementation

#endif

The #ifndef etc. preprocessor definitions allow it to be used multiple times.

PS. The topic becomes clearer once you realize C/C++ is 'dumb' and #include is merely a way to say "dump this text at this spot".

Solution 4 - C++

Basically a modified syntax of function declaration/definitions:

a2dd.h

class A2DD
{
private:
  int gx;
  int gy;

public:
  A2DD(int x,int y);

  int getSum();
};

a2dd.cpp

A2DD::A2DD(int x,int y)
{
  gx = x;
  gy = y;
}

int A2DD::getSum()
{
  return gx + gy;
}

Solution 5 - C++

A2DD.h

class A2DD
{
  private:
  int gx;
  int gy;

  public:
  A2DD(int x,int y);

  int getSum();
};

A2DD.cpp

  A2DD::A2DD(int x,int y)
  {
    gx = x;
    gy = y;
  }

  int A2DD::getSum()
  {
    return gx + gy;
  }

The idea is to keep all function signatures and members in the header file.
This will allow other project files to see how the class looks like without having to know the implementation.

And besides that, you can then include other header files in the implementation instead of the header. This is important because whichever headers are included in your header file will be included (inherited) in any other file that includes your header file.

Solution 6 - C++

You leave the declarations in the header file:

class A2DD
{
  private:
  int gx;
  int gy;

  public:
    A2DD(int x,int y); // leave the declarations here
    int getSum();
};

And put the definitions in the implementation file.

A2DD::A2DD(int x,int y) // prefix the definitions with the class name
{
  gx = x;
  gy = y;
}

int A2DD::getSum()
{
  return gx + gy;
}

You could mix the two (leave getSum() definition in the header for instance). This is useful since it gives the compiler a better chance at inlining for example. But it also means that changing the implementation (if left in the header) could trigger a rebuild of all the other files that include the header.

Note that for templates, you need to keep it all in the headers.

Solution 7 - C++

Usually you put only declarations and really short inline functions in the header file:

For instance:

class A {
 public:
  A(); // only declaration in the .h unless only a short initialization list is used.

  inline int GetA() const {
    return a_;
  }

  void DoSomethingCoplex(); // only declaration
  private:
   int a_;
 };

Solution 8 - C++

I won't refer too your example as it is quite simple for a general answer (for example it doesn't contain templated functions ,which force you to implement them on the header) , what I follow as a rule of thumb is the pimpl idiom

It has quite some benefits as you get faster compilation times and the syntactic sugar :

class->member instead of class.member

The only drawback is the extra pointer you pay.

Attributions

All content for this solution is sourced from the original question on Stackoverflow.

The content on this page is licensed under the Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International (CC BY-SA 4.0) license.

Content TypeOriginal AuthorOriginal Content on Stackoverflow
QuestiondrdrdrView Question on Stackoverflow
Solution 1 - C++Ferenc DeakView Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 2 - C++NickView Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 3 - C++j rivView Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 4 - C++CorbinView Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 5 - C++Yochai TimmerView Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 6 - C++MatView Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 7 - C++Ivaylo StrandjevView Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 8 - C++Spyros MourelatosView Answer on Stackoverflow