Return in generator together with yield in Python 3.3

PythonPython 3.xGenerator

Python Problem Overview


In Python 2 there was an error when return was together with yield in function definition. But for this code in Python 3.3

def f():
  return 3
  yield 2
  
x = f()
print(x.__next__())

there is no error that return is used in function with yield. However when the function __next__ is called then there is thrown exception StopIteration. Why there is not just returned value 3? Is this return somehow ignored?

Python Solutions


Solution 1 - Python

This is a new feature in Python 3.3 (as a comment notes, it doesn't even work in 3.2). Much like return in a generator has long been equivalent to raise StopIteration(), return <something> in a generator is now equivalent to raise StopIteration(<something>). For that reason, the exception you're seeing should be printed as StopIteration: 3, and the value is accessible through the attribute value on the exception object. If the generator is delegated to using the (also new) yield from syntax, it is the result. See PEP 380 for details.

def f():
    return 1
    yield 2

def g():
    x = yield from f()
    print(x)

# g is still a generator so we need to iterate to run it:
for _ in g():
    pass

This prints 1, but not 2.

Solution 2 - Python

The return value is not ignored, but generators only yield values, a return just ends the generator, in this case early. Advancing the generator never reaches the yield statement in that case.

Whenever a iterator reaches the 'end' of the values to yield, a StopIteration must be raised. Generators are no exception. As of Python 3.3 however, any return expression becomes the value of the exception:

>>> def gen():
...     return 3
...     yield 2
... 
>>> try:
...     next(gen())
... except StopIteration as ex:
...     e = ex
... 
>>> e
StopIteration(3,)
>>> e.value
3

Use the next() function to advance iterators, instead of calling .__next__() directly:

print(next(x))

Attributions

All content for this solution is sourced from the original question on Stackoverflow.

The content on this page is licensed under the Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International (CC BY-SA 4.0) license.

Content TypeOriginal AuthorOriginal Content on Stackoverflow
QuestionscdmbView Question on Stackoverflow
Solution 1 - Pythonuser395760View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 2 - PythonMartijn PietersView Answer on Stackoverflow