React Native - Difference between onChange vs onChangeText of TextInput

React Native

React Native Problem Overview


I'm not sure when to use onChange vs onChangeText in a TextInput component. I know onChangeText accepts the changed text as an arg in the callback, but is that why you would use onChangeText, since you can then update state within the callback?

React Native Solutions


Solution 1 - React Native

UPDATE 26.08.2019

Since the initial version of the answer, TextInput's API has changed, and answer below is no longer valid. I haven't worked with react-native for more than 2 years now, so I can't really tell which version had these changes.

Regarding the answer, onChangeText is still a simple prop, that gives whatever is the value of the input field on every change.

onChange on the other hand, passes an event with { nativeEvent: { eventCount, target, text} } (as mentioned in the comment to this answer). Now, I cannot tell with confidence, why do you need eventCount and target. I can only state, that eventCount is increased every time you interact with TextInput component (character added, removed, all deleted, value pasted) and target is a unique integer for that TextInput field. And text is the same value as in onChangeText

So basically, I would suggest to use onChangeText, as a more straight forward prop.

If you want to accomplish functionality like in the old answer(below), you can create custom component, that wraps TextInput and receives custom properties and passes them to the onChange prop later. Example below:

const MyTextInput = ({ value, name, type, onChange }) => {
  return (
    <TextInput
      value={value}
      onChangeText={text => onChange({ name, type, text })}
    />
  );
};

And then use it whenever you need to use TextInput

handleChange(event) {
    const {name, type, text} = event;
    let processedData = text;
    if(type==='text') {
        processedData = value.toUpperCase();
    } else if (type==='number') {
        processedData = value * 2;
    }
    this.setState({[name]: processedData})
}

<MyTextInput name="username" type="text" value={this.state.username} onChange={this.handleChange}}>
<MyTextInput name="password" type="number" value={this.state.password} onChange={this.handleChange}}>

OLD ANSWER

onChangeText is basically a simplified version of onChange, so you can easily use it, without the hassle of going through event.target.value to get changed value.

So, when should you use onChange and when onChangeText?
If you have simple form with few textinputs, or simple logic, you can go straight away and use onChangeText

<TextInput value={this.state.name} onChangeText={(text) => this.setState({name: text})}>

If you have more complicated forms and/or you have more logic in handling data (like handling text differently from number) when user changes input, then you are better of with onChange, because it gives you more flexibility. For example:

handleChange(event) {
    const {name, type, value} = event.nativeEvent;
    let processedData = value;
    if(type==='text') {
        processedData = value.toUpperCase();
    } else if (type==='number') {
        processedData = value * 2;
    }
    this.setState({[name]: processedData})
}

<TextInput name="username" type="text" value={this.state.username} onChange={this.handleChange}}>
<TextInput name="password" type="number" value={this.state.password} onChange={this.handleChange}}>

Solution 2 - React Native

Use it like this:

<Input label='First Name' onChange={this.onChange} value={this.state.first}/>
onChange = (event) => {    
  const {eventCount, target, text} = event.nativeEvent;
  this.setState({first:text});
};

The target attribute seems useless. It doesn't look like you can attach data attributes to react-native elements and retrieve them from the target element like you can in react because the app is not a browser.

With react, we're told it's better practice to not attach inline functions to the onChange event for performance reasons. We're supposed to use custom props or data-* attributes on the HTML element and retrieve the information from e.target inside the onChange handler.

But with react-native it seems this format of passing data is actually acceptable:

<Input 
      label='First Name' 
      onChangeText={text=>this.onChange('first',text,'anotherValueIWantToPass')} 
      value={this.state.first}/>

Attributions

All content for this solution is sourced from the original question on Stackoverflow.

The content on this page is licensed under the Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International (CC BY-SA 4.0) license.

Content TypeOriginal AuthorOriginal Content on Stackoverflow
QuestionjamesvphanView Question on Stackoverflow
Solution 1 - React NativemagneticzView Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 2 - React NativeMarcView Answer on Stackoverflow