PHP call_user_func vs. just calling function

PhpFunction

Php Problem Overview


I'm sure there's a very easy explanation for this. What is the difference between this:

function barber($type){
    echo "You wanted a $type haircut, no problem\n";
}
call_user_func('barber', "mushroom");
call_user_func('barber', "shave");

... and this (and what are the benefits?):

function barber($type){
    echo "You wanted a $type haircut, no problem\n";
}
barber('mushroom');
barber('shave');

Php Solutions


Solution 1 - Php

Always use the actual function name when you know it.

call_user_func is for calling functions whose name you don't know ahead of time but it is much less efficient since the program has to lookup the function at runtime.

Solution 2 - Php

Although you can call variable function names this way:

function printIt($str) { print($str); }

$funcname = 'printIt';
$funcname('Hello world!');

there are cases where you don't know how many arguments you're passing. Consider the following:

function someFunc() {
  $args = func_get_args();
  // do something
}

call_user_func_array('someFunc',array('one','two','three'));

It's also handy for calling static and object methods, respectively:

call_user_func(array('someClass','someFunc'),$arg);
call_user_func(array($myObj,'someFunc'),$arg);

Solution 3 - Php

the call_user_func option is there so you can do things like:

$dynamicFunctionName = "barber";

call_user_func($dynamicFunctionName, 'mushroom');

where the dynamicFunctionName string could be more exciting and generated at run-time. You shouldn't use call_user_func unless you have to, because it is slower.

Solution 4 - Php

With PHP 7 you can use the nicer variable-function syntax everywhere. It works with static/instance functions, and it can take an array of parameters. More info at https://trowski.com/2015/06/20/php-callable-paradox

$ret = $callable(...$params);

Solution 5 - Php

I imagine it is useful for calling a function that you don't know the name of in advance... Something like:

switch($value):
{
  case 7:
  $func = 'run';
  break;
  default:
  $func = 'stop';
  break;
}

call_user_func($func, 'stuff');

Solution 6 - Php

There is no benefits calling the function like that because I think it mainly used to call "user" function (like plugin) because editing core file is not good option. here are dirty example used by Wordpress

<?php
/* 
* my_plugin.php
*/

function myLocation($content){
  return str_replace('@', 'world', $content);
}

function myName($content){
  return $content."Tasikmalaya";
}

add_filter('the_content', 'myLocation');
add_filter('the_content', 'myName');

?>

...

<?php
/*
* core.php
* read only
*/

$content = "hello @ my name is ";
$listFunc = array();

// store user function to array (in my_plugin.php)
function add_filter($fName, $funct)
{
  $listFunc[$fName]= $funct;
}

// execute list user defined function
function apply_filter($funct, $content)
{
  global $listFunc;
  
  if(isset($listFunc))
  {
    foreach($listFunc as $key => $value)
    {
      if($key == $funct)
      {
        $content = call_user_func($listFunc[$key], $content);
      }
    }
  }
  return $content;
}

function the_content()
{
  $content = apply_filter('the_content', $content);
  echo $content;
}
 
?>

....

<?php
require_once("core.php");
require_once("my_plugin.php");

the_content(); // hello world my name is Tasikmalaya
?>

output

hello world my name is Tasikmalaya

Solution 7 - Php

in your first example you're using function name which is a string. it might come from outside or be determined on the fly. that is, you don't know what function will need to be run at the moment of the code creation.

Solution 8 - Php

When using namespaces, call_user_func() is the only way to run a function you don't know the name of beforehand, for example:

$function = '\Utilities\SearchTools::getCurrency';
call_user_func($function,'USA');

If all your functions were in the same namespace, then it wouldn't be such an issue, as you could use something like this:

$function = 'getCurrency';
$function('USA');

Edit: Following @Jannis saying that I'm wrong I did a little more testing, and wasn't having much luck:

<?php
namespace Foo {

	class Bar {
		public static function getBar() {
			return 'Bar';
		}
	}
	echo "<h1>Bar: ".\Foo\Bar::getBar()."</h1>";
	// outputs 'Bar: Bar'
	$function = '\Foo\Bar::getBar';
	echo "<h1>Bar: ".$function()."</h1>";
	// outputs 'Fatal error: Call to undefined function \Foo\Bar::getBar()'
	$function = '\Foo\Bar\getBar';
	echo "<h1>Bar: ".$function()."</h1>";
	// outputs 'Fatal error: Call to undefined function \foo\Bar\getBar()'
}

You can see the output results here: https://3v4l.org/iBERh it seems the second method works for PHP 7 onwards, but not PHP 5.6.

Attributions

All content for this solution is sourced from the original question on Stackoverflow.

The content on this page is licensed under the Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International (CC BY-SA 4.0) license.

Content TypeOriginal AuthorOriginal Content on Stackoverflow
QuestionjayView Question on Stackoverflow
Solution 1 - PhpKaiView Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 2 - PhpLucas OmanView Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 3 - PhpBrian SchrothView Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 4 - PhpmilsView Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 5 - PhppivotalView Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 6 - PhpuingteaView Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 7 - PhpSilentGhostView Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 8 - PhpThomasRedstoneView Answer on Stackoverflow