LINQ Using Max() to select a single row

C#.NetLinq

C# Problem Overview


I'm using LINQ on an IQueryable returned from NHibernate and I need to select the row with the maximum value(s) in a couple of fields.

I've simplified the bit that I'm sticking on. I need to select the one row from my table with the maximum value in one field.

var table = new Table { new Row(id: 1, status: 10), new Row(id: 2, status: 20) }

from u in table
group u by 1 into g
where u.Status == g.Max(u => u.Status)
select u

This is incorrect but I can't work out the right form.

BTW, what I'm actually trying to achieve is approximately this:

var clientAddress = this.repository.GetAll()
    .GroupBy(a => a)
    .SelectMany(
            g =>
            g.Where(
                a =>
                a.Reference == clientReference && 
                a.Status == ClientStatus.Live && 
                a.AddressReference == g.Max(x => x.AddressReference) && 
                a.StartDate == g.Max(x => x.StartDate)))
    .SingleOrDefault();

I started with the above lambda but I've been using LINQPad to try and work out the syntax for selecting the Max().

UPDATE

Removing the GroupBy was key.

var all = this.repository.GetAll();

var address = all
            .Where(
                a =>
                a.Reference == clientReference && 
                a.Status == ClientStatus.Live && 
                a.StartDate == all.Max(x => x.StartDate) &&
                a.AddressReference == all.Max(x => x.AddressReference))
            .SingleOrDefault();

C# Solutions


Solution 1 - C#

I don't see why you are grouping here.

Try this:

var maxValue = table.Max(x => x.Status)
var result = table.First(x => x.Status == maxValue);

An alternate approach that would iterate table only once would be this:

var result = table.OrderByDescending(x => x.Status).First();

This is helpful if table is an IEnumerable<T> that is not present in memory or that is calculated on the fly.

Solution 2 - C#

You can also do:

(from u in table
orderby u.Status descending
select u).Take(1);

Solution 3 - C#

You can group by status and select a row from the largest group:

table.GroupBy(r => r.Status).OrderByDescending(g => g.Key).First().First();

The first First() gets the first group (the set of rows with the largest status); the second First() gets the first row in that group.
If the status is always unqiue, you can replace the second First() with Single().

Solution 4 - C#

Addressing the first question, if you need to take several rows grouped by certain criteria with the other column with max value you can do something like this:

var query =
    from u1 in table
    join u2 in (
        from u in table
        group u by u.GroupId into g
        select new { GroupId = g.Key, MaxStatus = g.Max(x => x.Status) }
    ) on new { u1.GroupId, u1.Status } equals new { u2.GroupId, Status = u2.MaxStatus}
    select u1;

Solution 5 - C#

What about this idea: It's better than

  1. Select max
  2. Select by max value

var maxRow = table.Aggregate(
  (a, b) => a.Status > b.Status ? a : b  // whatever you need to compare
);

Solution 6 - C#

More one example:

Follow:

 qryAux = (from q in qryAux where
            q.OrdSeq == (from pp in Sessao.Query<NameTable>() where pp.FieldPk
            == q.FieldPk select pp.OrdSeq).Max() select q);

Equals:

 select t.*   from nametable t  where t.OrdSeq =
        (select max(t2.OrdSeq) from nametable t2 where t2.FieldPk= t.FieldPk)

Solution 7 - C#

Simply in one line:

var result = table.First(x => x.Status == table.Max(y => y.Status));

Notice that there are two action. the inner action is for finding the max value, the outer action is for get the desired object.

Attributions

All content for this solution is sourced from the original question on Stackoverflow.

The content on this page is licensed under the Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International (CC BY-SA 4.0) license.

Content TypeOriginal AuthorOriginal Content on Stackoverflow
QuestionBogginView Question on Stackoverflow
Solution 1 - C#Daniel HilgarthView Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 2 - C#KAPIL SHARMAView Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 3 - C#SLaksView Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 4 - C#Dmitry KominView Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 5 - C#PavelPView Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 6 - C#SantanaFireView Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 7 - C#ShneorView Answer on Stackoverflow