Java: Calling a super method which calls an overridden method
JavaInheritanceOverridingSuperJava Problem Overview
public class SuperClass
{
public void method1()
{
System.out.println("superclass method1");
this.method2();
}
public void method2()
{
System.out.println("superclass method2");
}
}
public class SubClass extends SuperClass
{
@Override
public void method1()
{
System.out.println("subclass method1");
super.method1();
}
@Override
public void method2()
{
System.out.println("subclass method2");
}
}
public class Demo
{
public static void main(String[] args)
{
SubClass mSubClass = new SubClass();
mSubClass.method1();
}
}
my expected output:
> subclass method1
> superclass method1
> superclass method2
actual output:
> subclass method1
> superclass method1
> subclass method2
I know technically I have overriden a public method, but I figured that because I was calling the super, any calls within the super would stay in the super, this isn't happening. Any ideas as to how I can make it happen?
Java Solutions
Solution 1 - Java
The keyword super doesn't "stick". Every method call is handled individually, so even if you got to SuperClass.method1() by calling super, that doesn't influence any other method call that you might make in the future.
That means there is no direct way to call SuperClass.method2() from SuperClass.method1() without going though SubClass.method2() unless you're working with an actual instance of SuperClass.
You can't even achieve the desired effect using Reflection (see the documentation of java.lang.reflect.Method.invoke(Object, Object...)).
[EDIT] There still seems to be some confusion. Let me try a different explanation.
When you invoke foo(), you actually invoke this.foo(). Java simply lets you omit the this. In the example in the question, the type of this is SubClass.
So when Java executes the code in SuperClass.method1(), it eventually arrives at this.method2();
Using super doesn't change the instance pointed to by this. So the call goes to SubClass.method2() since this is of type SubClass.
Maybe it's easier to understand when you imagine that Java passes this as a hidden first parameter:
public class SuperClass
{
public void method1(SuperClass this)
{
System.out.println("superclass method1");
this.method2(this); // <--- this == mSubClass
}
public void method2(SuperClass this)
{
System.out.println("superclass method2");
}
}
public class SubClass extends SuperClass
{
@Override
public void method1(SubClass this)
{
System.out.println("subclass method1");
super.method1(this);
}
@Override
public void method2(SubClass this)
{
System.out.println("subclass method2");
}
}
public class Demo
{
public static void main(String[] args)
{
SubClass mSubClass = new SubClass();
mSubClass.method1(mSubClass);
}
}
If you follow the call stack, you can see that this never changes, it's always the instance created in main().
Solution 2 - Java
You can only access overridden methods in the overriding methods (or in other methods of the overriding class).
So: either don't override method2() or call super.method2() inside the overridden version.
Solution 3 - Java
I think of it this way
+----------------+
| super |
+----------------+ <-----------------+
| +------------+ | |
| | this | | <-+ |
| +------------+ | | |
| | @method1() | | | |
| | @method2() | | | |
| +------------+ | | |
| method4() | | |
| method5() | | |
+----------------+ | |
We instantiate that class, not that one!
Let me move that subclass a little to the left to reveal what's beneath... (Man, I do love ASCII graphics)
We are here
|
/ +----------------+
| | super |
v +----------------+
+------------+ |
| this | |
+------------+ |
| @method1() | method1() |
| @method2() | method2() |
+------------+ method3() |
| method4() |
| method5() |
+----------------+
Then we call the method
over here...
| +----------------+
_____/ | super |
/ +----------------+
| +------------+ | bar() |
| | this | | foo() |
| +------------+ | method0() |
+-> | @method1() |--->| method1() | <------------------------------+
| @method2() | ^ | method2() | |
+------------+ | | method3() | |
| | method4() | |
| | method5() | |
| +----------------+ |
\______________________________________ |
\ |
| |
...which calls super, thus calling the super's method1() here, so that that
method (the overidden one) is executed instead[of the overriding one].
Keep in mind that, in the inheritance hierarchy, since the instantiated
class is the sub one, for methods called via super.something() everything
is the same except for one thing (two, actually): "this" means "the only
this we have" (a pointer to the class we have instantiated, the
subclass), even when java syntax allows us to omit "this" (most of the
time); "super", though, is polymorphism-aware and always refers to the
superclass of the class (instantiated or not) that we're actually
executing code from ("this" is about objects [and can't be used in a
static context], super is about classes).
In other words, quoting from the [Java Language Specification][1]:
> The form super.Identifier refers to the field named Identifier of the
> current object, but with the current object viewed as an instance of
> the superclass of the current class.
>
> The form T.super.Identifier refers to the field named Identifier of
> the lexically enclosing instance corresponding to T, but with that
> instance viewed as an instance of the superclass of T.
In layman's terms, this is basically an object (the* object; the very same object you can move around in variables), the instance of the instantiated class, a plain variable in the data domain; super is like a pointer to a borrowed block of code that you want to be executed, more like a mere function call, and it's relative to the class where it is called.
Therefore if you use super from the superclass you get code from the superduper class [the grandparent] executed), while if you use this (or if it's used implicitly) from a superclass it keeps pointing to the subclass (because nobody has changed it - and nobody could).
[1]: http://docs.oracle.com/javase/specs/jls/se7/html/jls-15.html#jls-15.11.2 "JLS"
Solution 4 - Java
You're using the this keyword which actually refers to the "currently running instance of the object you're using", that is, you're invoking this.method2(); on your superclass, that is, it will call the method2() on the object you're using, which is the SubClass.
Solution 5 - Java
If you don't want superClass.method1 to call subClass.method2, make method2 private so it cannot be overridden.
Here's a suggestion:
public class SuperClass {
public void method1() {
System.out.println("superclass method1");
this.internalMethod2();
}
public void method2() {
// this method can be overridden.
// It can still be invoked by a childclass using super
internalMethod2();
}
private void internalMethod2() {
// this one cannot. Call this one if you want to be sure to use
// this implementation.
System.out.println("superclass method2");
}
}
public class SubClass extends SuperClass {
@Override
public void method1() {
System.out.println("subclass method1");
super.method1();
}
@Override
public void method2() {
System.out.println("subclass method2");
}
}
If it didn't work this way, polymorphism would be impossible (or at least not even half as useful).
Solution 6 - Java
class SuperClass
{
public void method1()
{
System.out.println("superclass method1");
SuperClass se=new SuperClass();
se.method2();
}
public void method2()
{
System.out.println("superclass method2");
}
}
class SubClass extends SuperClass
{
@Override
public void method1()
{
System.out.println("subclass method1");
super.method1();
}
@Override
public void method2()
{
System.out.println("subclass method2");
}
}
calling
SubClass mSubClass = new SubClass();
mSubClass.method1();
outputs
> subclass method1
superclass method1
superclass method2
Solution 7 - Java
Since the only way to avoid a method to get overriden is to use the keyword super, I've thought to move up the method2() from SuperClass to another new Base class and then call it from SuperClass:
class Base
{
public void method2()
{
System.out.println("superclass method2");
}
}
class SuperClass extends Base
{
public void method1()
{
System.out.println("superclass method1");
super.method2();
}
}
class SubClass extends SuperClass
{
@Override
public void method1()
{
System.out.println("subclass method1");
super.method1();
}
@Override
public void method2()
{
System.out.println("subclass method2");
}
}
public class Demo
{
public static void main(String[] args)
{
SubClass mSubClass = new SubClass();
mSubClass.method1();
}
}
Output:
subclass method1
superclass method1
superclass method2
Solution 8 - Java
this always refers to currently executing object.
To further illustrate the point here is a simple sketch:
+----------------+
| Subclass |
|----------------|
| @method1() |
| @method2() |
| |
| +------------+ |
| | Superclass | |
| |------------| |
| | method1() | |
| | method2() | |
| +------------+ |
+----------------+
If you have an instance of the outer box, a Subclass object, wherever you happen to venture inside the box, even into the Superclass 'area', it is still the instance of the outer box.
What's more, in this program there is only one object that gets created out of the three classes, so this can only ever refer to one thing and it is:
as shown in the Netbeans 'Heap Walker'.
Solution 9 - Java
I don't believe you can do it directly. One workaround would be to have a private internal implementation of method2 in the superclass, and call that. For example:
public class SuperClass
{
public void method1()
{
System.out.println("superclass method1");
this.internalMethod2();
}
public void method2()
{
this.internalMethod2();
}
private void internalMethod2()
{
System.out.println("superclass method2");
}
}
Solution 10 - Java
"this" keyword refers to current class reference. That means, when it is used inside the method, the 'current' class is still SubClass and so, the answer is explained.
Solution 11 - Java
To summarize, this points to current object and the method invocation in java is polymorphic by nature. So, method selection for execution, totally depends upon object pointed by this. Therefore, invoking method method2() from parent class invokes method2() of child class, as the this points to object of child class. The definition of this doesn't changes, irrespective of whichever class it's used.
PS. unlike methods, member variables of class are not polymorphic.
Solution 12 - Java
During my research for a similar case, I have been ending up by checking the stack trace in the subclass method to find out from where the call is coming from. There are probably smarter ways to do so, but it works out for me and it's a dynamic approach.
public void method2(){
Exception ex=new Exception();
StackTraceElement[] ste=ex.getStackTrace();
if(ste[1].getClassName().equals(this.getClass().getSuperclass().getName())){
super.method2();
}
else{
//subclass method2 code
}
}
I think the question to have a solution for the case is reasonable. There are of course ways to solve the issue with different method names or even different parameter types, like already mentioned in the thread, but in my case I dindn't like to confuse by different method names.
Solution 13 - Java
Further more extended the output of the raised question, this will give more insight on the access specifier and override behavior.
package overridefunction;
public class SuperClass
{
public void method1()
{
System.out.println("superclass method1");
this.method2();
this.method3();
this.method4();
this.method5();
}
public void method2()
{
System.out.println("superclass method2");
}
private void method3()
{
System.out.println("superclass method3");
}
protected void method4()
{
System.out.println("superclass method4");
}
void method5()
{
System.out.println("superclass method5");
}
}
package overridefunction;
public class SubClass extends SuperClass
{
@Override
public void method1()
{
System.out.println("subclass method1");
super.method1();
}
@Override
public void method2()
{
System.out.println("subclass method2");
}
// @Override
private void method3()
{
System.out.println("subclass method3");
}
@Override
protected void method4()
{
System.out.println("subclass method4");
}
@Override
void method5()
{
System.out.println("subclass method5");
}
}
package overridefunction;
public class Demo
{
public static void main(String[] args)
{
SubClass mSubClass = new SubClass();
mSubClass.method1();
}
}
subclass method1
superclass method1
subclass method2
superclass method3
subclass method4
subclass method5