git rebase without changing commit timestamps

Git Problem Overview

Would it make sense to perform git rebase while preserving the commit timestamps?

I believe a consequence would be that the new branch will not necessarily have commit dates chronologically. Is that theoretically possible at all? (e.g. using plumbing commands; just curious here)

If it is theoretically possible, then is it possible in practice with rebase, not to change the timestamps?

For example, assume I have the following tree:

master <jun 2010>
  |
  :
  :
  :     oldbranch <feb 1984>
  :     /
oldcommit <jan 1984>

Now, if I rebase oldbranch on master, the date of the commit changes from feb 1984 to jun 2010. Is it possible to change that behaviour so that the commit timestamp is not changed? In the end I would thus obtain:

      oldbranch <feb 1984>
      /
 master <jun 2010>
    |
    :

Would that make sense at all? Is it even allowed in git to have a history where an old commit has a more recent commit as a parent?

Git Solutions

Solution 1 - Git

Update June 2014: David Fraser mentions in the comments a solution also detailed in "Change timestamps while rebasing git branch", using the option --committer-date-is-author-date (introduced initially in Jan. 2009 in commit 3f01ad6

> Note that the --committer-date-is-author-date option seems to leave the author timestamp, and set the committer timestamp to be the same as the original author timestamp, which is what the OP Olivier Verdier wanted. > > I found the last commit with the correct date and did: > > git rebase --committer-date-is-author-date SHA

See git am:

> --committer-date-is-author-date > > By default the command records the date from the e-mail message as the commit author date, and uses the time of commit creation as the committer date.
This allows the user to lie about the committer date by using the same value as the author date.

Note: with Git 2.29 (Q4 2020), git rebase --committer-date-is-author-date or --ignore-date will also work with:

interactive rebase (rebase -i/rebase --interactive)
for the root commit (git rebase --root)

See "Change timestamps while rebasing git branch".

(Original answer, June 2012)

You could try, for a ~~non-interactive~~ rebase
(see just above: with Git 2.29, Q4 2020, that will work with an interactive rebase as well)

git rebase --ignore-date

(from this SO answer)

This is passed to git am, which mentions:

 --ignore-date

> By default the command records the date from the e-mail message as the commit author date, and uses the time of commit creation as the committer date.
This allows the user to lie about the author date by using the same value as the committer date.

For git rebase, this option is "Incompatible with the --interactive option."

Since you can change at will the timestamp of old commit date (with git filter-branch), I suppose you can organize your Git history with whatever commit date order you want/need, even set it to the future!.

As Olivier mentions in his question, the author date is never changed by a rebase;
From the Pro Git Book:

> - The author is the person who originally wrote the work, > - whereas the committer is the person who last applied the work. > > So, if you send in a patch to a project and one of the core members applies the patch, both of you get credit.

To be extra clear, in this instance, as Olivier comments:

> the --ignore-date does the opposite of what I was trying to achieve!
Namely, it erases the author's timestamp and replace them with the commits timestamps!
So the right answer to my question is:
Do not do anything, since git rebase does actually not change authors' timestamps by default.

As DylanYoung adds in the comments, using "How to identify conflicting commits by hash during git rebase?":

> Using the SEQUENCE_EDITOR variable and rebase interactive, you would just loop over the current todo list and add a command setting the GIT_COMMITER_DATE to the date of the original commit before each commit in the todo. > > It's a bit less fiddly because you have the list of original commits to start with (you don't have to hack into git internals to find it), but a bit more work because you have to handle the entire list at once. – > > Once you're able to identify the original commit you can do something like: > > git rebase -x 'GIT_COMMITTER_DATE="git show -s --format=%ci get_current_commit" git commit --amend --no-edit

Solution 2 - Git

If you've already screwed up the commit dates (perhaps with a rebase) and want to reset them to their corresponding author dates, you can run:

git filter-branch --env-filter 'GIT_COMMITTER_DATE=$GIT_AUTHOR_DATE; export GIT_COMMITTER_DATE'

Solution 3 - Git

A crucial question of Von C helped me understand what is going on: when your rebase, the committer's timestamp changes, but not the author's timestamp, which suddenly all makes sense. So my question was actually not precise enough.

The answer is that rebase actually doesn't change the author's timestamps (you don't need to do anything for that), which suits me perfectly.

Solution 4 - Git

By default, git rebase will set the committer's timestamp to the time when the new commit is created, but keep the author's timestamp intact. Most of time, this is the desired behavior, but at some scenarios, we dot not wish to change the commiter's timestamp either. How can we accomplish that? Well, here is the trick I usually do.

First, make sure each of the commits you are about to rebase has a unique commit message and author timestamp (This is where is trick needs improvements, currently it suits my needs though).

Before the rebase, record the committer's timestamp, author's timestamp and commit message of all the commits which will be rebased to a file.

#NOTE: BASE is the commit where your rebase begins
git log --pretty='%ct %at %s' BASE..HEAD > hashlog

Then, let the actual rebase take place.

Finally, we replace the current committer's timestamp with the one recorded in the file if the commit message is the same by using git filter-branch.

 git filter-branch --env-filter '__date=$(__log=$(git log -1 --pretty="%at %s" $GIT_COMMIT); grep -m 1 "$__log" ../../hashlog | cut -d" " -f1); test -n "$__date" && export GIT_COMMITTER_DATE=$__date || cat'

If something goes wrong, just checkout git reflog or all the refs/original/ refs.

Furthormore, you can do the similar thing to the author's timestamp.

For example, if the author's timestamp of some commits are out of order, and without rearrange these commits, we just want the author's timestamp to show in order, then the following commands will help.

git log --pretty='%at %s' COMMIT1..COMMIT2 > hashlog
join -1 1 -2 1 <(cat hashlog | cut -f 1 | sort -nr | awk '{ print NR" "$1 }') <(cat hashlog | awk '{ print NR" "$0 }') | cut -d" " -f2,4- > hashlog_
mv hashlog_ hashlog
git filter-branch --env-filter '__date=$(__log=$(git log -1 --pretty="%s" $GIT_COMMIT); grep -m 1 "$__log" ../../hashlog | cut -d" " -f1); test -n "$__date" && export GIT_AUTHOR_DATE=$__date || cat'

Solution 5 - Git

post-rewrite hook

This hook works for all of git rebase, git pull --rebase and git commit --amend.

.git/hooks/post-rewrite

set -eu
echo post-rewrite
if [ ! "${CIROSANTILLI_GITHOOKS_DISABLE:-0}" = 1 ]; then
  declare -a olds
  declare -A oldnew
  while IFS= read -r line; do
    echo "$line"
    old="$(echo "$line" | cut -d ' ' -f1)"
    new="$(echo "$line" | cut -d ' ' -f2)"
    oldnew[$old]="$new"
    olds+=("$old")
    news+=("$new")
  done
  git reset --hard "${news[0]}~"
  for old in "${olds[@]}"; do
    new="${oldnew[$old]}"
    git cherry-pick "$new" &>/dev/null
    olddate="$(git log --format='%cd' -n 1 "$old")"
    CIROSANTILLI_GITHOOKS_DISABLE=1 \
      GIT_COMMITTER_DATE="$olddate" \
      git commit \
      --amend \
      --no-edit \
      --no-verify \
      &>/dev/null \
    ;
  done
  echo
fi

GitHub upstream.

Don't forget to:

chmod +x .git/hooks/post-rewrite

This is a good way to do --committer-date-is-author-date by default on chosen repos, before someone finally patches a config to set it by default.

And it also works with --committer-date-is-author-date which does not seem to be exposed on git pull --rebase.

Solution 6 - Git

This is the command I used for my case:

GIT_AUTHOR_EMAIL=xaionaro@dx.center git rebase --root -x "bash -c 'git commit --amend --reset-author -CHEAD --date=\"\$(git show --format=%ad -s)\"'"

Here git show --format=%ad -s extracts the current date and --date re-enforces it. And rebase --root -x executes the command bash -c 'git commit --amend --reset-author -CHEAD --date="$(git show --format=%ad -s)"' for each commit.

Content Type	Original Author	Original Content on Stackoverflow
Question	Olivier Verdier	View Question on Stackoverflow
Solution 1 - Git	VonC	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 2 - Git	Andy	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 3 - Git	Olivier Verdier	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 4 - Git	weynhamz	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 5 - Git	Ciro Santilli Путлер Капут 六四事	View Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 6 - Git	Dmitry Yu Okunev	View Answer on Stackoverflow