Elegant way to perform tuple arithmetic
PythonPython 2.7NumpyTuplesPython Problem Overview
What is the most elegant and concise way (without creating my own class with operator overloading) to perform tuple arithmetic in Python 2.7?
Lets say I have two tuples:
a = (10, 10)
b = (4, 4)
My intended result is
c = a - b = (6, 6)
I currently use:
c = (a[0] - b[0], a[1] - b[1])
I also tried:
c = tuple([(i - j) for i in a for j in b])
but the result was (6, 6, 6, 6)
. I believe the above works as a nested for loops resulting in 4 iterations and 4 values in the result.
Python Solutions
Solution 1 - Python
If you're looking for fast, you can use numpy:
>>> import numpy
>>> numpy.subtract((10, 10), (4, 4))
array([6, 6])
and if you want to keep it in a tuple:
>>> tuple(numpy.subtract((10, 10), (4, 4)))
(6, 6)
Solution 2 - Python
One option would be,
>>> from operator import sub
>>> c = tuple(map(sub, a, b))
>>> c
(6, 6)
And itertools.imap
can serve as a replacement for map
.
Of course you can also use other functions from operator
to add
, mul
, div
, etc.
But I would seriously consider moving into another data structure since I don't think this type of problem is fit for tuple
s
Solution 3 - Python
Use zip
and a generator expression:
c = tuple(x-y for x, y in zip(a, b))
Demo:
>>> a = (10, 10)
>>> b = (4, 4)
>>> c = tuple(x-y for x, y in zip(a, b))
>>> c
(6, 6)
Use itertools.izip
for a memory efficient solution.
help on zip
:
>>> print zip.__doc__
zip(seq1 [, seq2 [...]]) -> [(seq1[0], seq2[0] ...), (...)]
Return a list of tuples, where each tuple contains the i-th element
from each of the argument sequences. The returned list is truncated
in length to the length of the shortest argument sequence.
Solution 4 - Python
JFYI, execution time in my laptop in 100000 times iteration
np.subtract(a, b)
: 0.18578505516052246
tuple(x - y for x, y in zip(a, b))
:
0.09348797798156738
tuple(map(lambda x, y: x - y, a, b))
: 0.07900381088256836
from operator import sub tuple(map(sub, a, b))
: 0.044342041015625
operator looks more elegant for me.
Solution 5 - Python
This can also be done just as nicely without an import at all, although lambda is often undesirable:
tuple(map(lambda x, y: x - y, a, b))
If you are looking to get the distance between two points on say a 2d coordinate plane you should use the absolute value of the subtraction of the pairs.
tuple(map(lambda x ,y: abs(x - y), a, b))
Solution 6 - Python
As an addition to Kohei Kawasaki's answer, for speed, the original solution was actually the fastest (For a length two tuple at least).
>>> timeit.timeit('tuple(map(add, a, b))',number=1000000,setup='from operator import add; a=(10,11); b=(1,2)')
0.6502681339999867
>>> timeit.timeit('(a[0] - b[0], a[1] - b[1])',number=1000000,setup='from operator import add; a=(10,11); b=(1,2)')
0.19015854899998885
>>>
Solution 7 - Python
Since in your question there only examples of 2-number-tuples, for such coordinate-like tuples, you may be good with simple built-in "complex" class:
>>> a=complex(7,5)
>>> b=complex(1,2)
>>> a-b
>>> c=a-b
>>> c
(6+3j)
>>> c.real
6.0
>>> c.imag
3.0
Solution 8 - Python
my element-wise tuple arithmetic helper
supported operations: +, -, /, *, d
operation = 'd' calculates distance between two points on a 2D coordinate plane
def tuplengine(tuple1, tuple2, operation):
"""
quick and dirty, element-wise, tuple arithmetic helper,
created on Sun May 28 07:06:16 2017
...
tuple1, tuple2: [named]tuples, both same length
operation: '+', '-', '/', '*', 'd'
operation 'd' returns distance between two points on a 2D coordinate plane (absolute value of the subtraction of pairs)
"""
assert len(tuple1) == len(tuple2), "tuple sizes doesn't match, tuple1: {}, tuple2: {}".format(len(tuple1), len(tuple2))
assert isinstance(tuple1, tuple) or tuple in type(tuple1).__bases__, "tuple1: not a [named]tuple"
assert isinstance(tuple2, tuple) or tuple in type(tuple2).__bases__, "tuple2: not a [named]tuple"
assert operation in list("+-/*d"), "operation has to be one of ['+','-','/','*','d']"
return eval("tuple( a{}b for a, b in zip( tuple1, tuple2 ))".format(operation)) \
if not operation == "d" \
else eval("tuple( abs(a-b) for a, b in zip( tuple1, tuple2 ))")