Check if a string isn't nil or empty in Lua

StringLua

String Problem Overview


I've some currently some Lua code using the following syntax:

if (foo == nil or foo == '') then
    foo = "some default value"
end

The goal of the if condition is to test foo is neither an empty string, neither a nil value.

Can this code be simplified in one if test instead two?

String Solutions


Solution 1 - String

One simple thing you could do is abstract the test inside a function.

local function isempty(s)
  return s == nil or s == ''
end

if isempty(foo) then
  foo = "default value"
end

Solution 2 - String

> Can this code be simplified in one if test instead two?

nil and '' are different values. If you need to test that s is neither, IMO you should just compare against both, because it makes your intent the most clear.

That and a few alternatives, with their generated bytecode:

if not foo or foo == '' then end
     GETGLOBAL       0 -1    ; foo
     TEST            0 0 0
     JMP             3       ; to 7
     GETGLOBAL       0 -1    ; foo
     EQ              0 0 -2  ; - ""
     JMP             0       ; to 7

if foo == nil or foo == '' then end
    GETGLOBAL       0 -1    ; foo
    EQ              1 0 -2  ; - nil
    JMP             3       ; to 7
    GETGLOBAL       0 -1    ; foo
    EQ              0 0 -3  ; - ""
    JMP             0       ; to 7

if (foo or '') == '' then end
   GETGLOBAL       0 -1    ; foo
   TEST            0 0 1
   JMP             1       ; to 5
   LOADK           0 -2    ; ""
   EQ              0 0 -2  ; - ""
   JMP             0       ; to 7

The second is fastest in Lua 5.1 and 5.2 (on my machine anyway), but difference is tiny. I'd go with the first for clarity's sake.

Attributions

All content for this solution is sourced from the original question on Stackoverflow.

The content on this page is licensed under the Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International (CC BY-SA 4.0) license.

Content TypeOriginal AuthorOriginal Content on Stackoverflow
QuestionUskiverView Question on Stackoverflow
Solution 1 - StringhugomgView Answer on Stackoverflow
Solution 2 - StringMudView Answer on Stackoverflow