Attr_accessor on class variables
RubyRuby Problem Overview
attr_accessor
does not work on the following code. The error says "undefined method 'things' for Parent:Class (NoMethodError)
":
class Parent
@@things = []
attr_accessor :things
end
Parent.things << :car
p Parent.things
However the following code works
class Parent
@@things = []
def self.things
@@things
end
def things
@@things
end
end
Parent.things << :car
p Parent.things
Ruby Solutions
Solution 1 - Ruby
attr_accessor
defines accessor methods for an instance. If you want class level auto-generated accessors you could use it on the metaclass
class Parent
@things = []
class << self
attr_accessor :things
end
end
Parent.things #=> []
Parent.things << :car
Parent.things #=> [:car]
but note that this creates a class level instance variable not a class variable. This is likely what you want anyway, as class variables behave differently than you might expect when dealing w/ inheritance. See "Class and Instance Variables In Ruby".
Solution 2 - Ruby
attr_accessor
generates accessors for instance variables. Class variables in Ruby are a very different thing, and they are usually not what you want. What you probably want here is a class instance variable. You can use attr_accessor
with class instance variables like so:
class Something
class <<self
attr_accessor :things
end
end
Then you can write Something.things = 12
and it will work.
Solution 3 - Ruby
Just some clarification: class variables won't be accessible using attr_accessor
. It's all about instance variables:
class SomeClass
class << self
attr_accessor :things
end
@things = []
end
because in Ruby, class is an instance of the class "Class" (God, I love to say that) and attr_accessor
sets accessor methods for instance variables.
Solution 4 - Ruby
This is probably the simplest way.
class Parent
def self.things
@@things ||= []
end
end
Parent.things << :car
p Parent.things
Solution 5 - Ruby
Аlso note that a singleton method is a method only for a single object. In Ruby, a Class is also an object, so it too can have singleton methods! So be aware of when you might be calling them.
Example:
class SomeClass
class << self
def test
end
end
end
test_obj = SomeClass.new
def test_obj.test_2
end
class << test_obj
def test_3
end
end
puts "Singleton methods of SomeClass"
puts SomeClass.singleton_methods
puts '------------------------------------------'
puts "Singleton methods of test_obj"
puts test_obj.singleton_methods
Singleton methods of SomeClass
test
Singleton methods of test_obj
test_2
test_3
Solution 6 - Ruby
Parent.class_variable_get(:@@things)
That would be the built-in way. In most cases this should be sufficient I think. No need to have a class variable accessor in the instance.
Solution 7 - Ruby
class Parent
@things = []
singleton_class.send(:attr_accessor, :things)
end
This pattern is most useful when you are defining accessors dynamically or creating them inside a method:
class Foo
def self.add_accessor(name)
singleton_class.send(:attr_accessor, name)
end
end
Foo.add_accessor :things
Foo.things = [:car]
Foo.things # => [:car]